PDA

View Full Version : Springbok Scrumhalf of world cup? Who?



kojack
25-07-07, 11:28 AM
Hi, im Kojack. personally I think we have an problem at scrumhalf (not with the talent or physical strength) but with the primary and alternative player. Fourie Du preez is excellent in attack and defence, but also is Ruan Pienaar? The difference between this two great players are Ruan lights a fire in the team that no one can. My opinion is Primary position Ruan Pienaar and Butch James. The other choice is Fourie and Andre Pretorius. Thanx

mclaren
25-07-07, 11:33 AM
Fourie the best

Bull
25-07-07, 11:53 AM
It has to be Fourie, the best scrummie in SA by far. I would also have picked Heinie Adams in front of Januarie. Ricky is unstable he gives away needless penalties and isn't alwys consistent in his play.

Dumbo
25-07-07, 12:22 PM
Plus from the outside looking in... it always looks like a Bok is going to smack him before the opposition does... No mention of Grant there Bull?

Bull
25-07-07, 01:13 PM
Who Peter Grant? Januarie is just silly, he does stupid stuff that can really cost a team.

koeloe
25-07-07, 01:23 PM
I think it must be Ruan Pienaar. He played better in the Super 14 than Fourie :)

I think it must be Ruan Pienaar. He played better in the Super 14 than Fourie

Bull
25-07-07, 01:26 PM
I think it must be Ruan Pienaar. He played better in the Super 14 than Fourie :)

I think it must be Ruan Pienaar. He played better in the Super 14 than Fourie
[/b]



Did you watch last years S14 or something?

Dumbo
25-07-07, 02:17 PM
:( must have...

BokMagic
25-07-07, 04:57 PM
Du Preez by a country mile gents. Sure Pienaar has all the skills, but Du Preez is just that little bit more refined a player. He`s got more composure under pressure, can kick equally well off both feet, and is brilliant falling back and covering. Also excellent in defense. Plus he`s used to making a very average no.10 in Hougaard look like a champion at CC and S14 level.

scuubasteve
26-07-07, 02:39 AM
I'd feel alot safer in the big games with Du Preez and Pretorius, than Pienaar and James, if I was South African. I don't find the Sharks pair as intimidating from an AB fan's perspective. Those two (FDP & AP) can really exploit opportunities in a game.

Leave Pienaar to carve up from the bench, like he did earlier this year for the Boks, with Steyn.

The Bok loosies can cover the inside channel sufficiently to make up for Pretorius' slighter weaker defensive abilities and he is a far better tactical kicker than Butch along with having more creativity.

FDP was the world's best halfback before he got injured (hard to say for a Kiwi). I don't think much will have changed once he comes back.

Cron07
27-07-07, 07:22 AM
It pretty much depends who we playing. Big games I would probably go with Du Preez and Butch, you know what you get from them, and theres less chance of those two going missing, although Pienaar does complement Butch's game probably better than Fourie.

Andre is a strange one, can be amazing, or go horribly missing and cost you a game, which would be a bit of a problem in a semi or final, but still a nice player to have on the bench to come on and open things up a bit.

munross
27-07-07, 07:44 AM
Fourie du Preez is by far the best scrum half in South Africa.Jake must play him with Andre Pretorius, Those two will get the back line moving.

big_P
27-07-07, 11:13 AM
was very impressed with peinaar during the tri nations. hes got a great punt on him

Rockstar
03-08-07, 10:28 AM
From a Sharks Fan...Fourie du Preez must be our no.1 srumhalf but DEF Ruan Pienaar a very close second. Januarie shouldnt have even been in the team!

Heinie Adams ahead of Pienaar!!!!????? What!!??

Heinie Adams ahead of Pienaar!!!!????? What!!??

mclaren
04-08-07, 06:48 PM
Fourie Du Preez nr 1 9. but I will play R.pienaar on the bench as a flyhalf and the young J. Vermaak of the lions as replacment 9

Dddooommm123
05-08-07, 12:06 AM
i have to agree with early coment with kojak but pienar is really talented u could find him a position somewhere else in the backline enabling both on the field?

McAlister
09-08-07, 12:00 AM
Fourie is the one in form and is the best of all

MerckZ
11-08-07, 09:47 AM
FdP would be my first choice - even though I'm a Sharks fan. Ruan can have such a huge impact on a game by coming off the bench - in whichever position he's needed. Wynand Olivier hopefully won't get a chance to ruin a game for us, as, with Ruan and Francois Steyn on the bench, we only need two replacement backs. Maybe Andre Pretorius too.



Peter Grant for Sharks 08!

36crazyfist
13-08-07, 01:21 PM
both of them deserve to be there, think first choice will come down to a matter of what tactics jake wants to employ...

only thing that i don't like about fourie, and ruan is guilty about it sometimes, is that the ball doesn't go out as quickly as it should...

Salamo
14-08-07, 08:41 AM
I think Fourie would be the perfect one because he is big and can score tries

Kalium
14-08-07, 08:52 AM
Play Ruan, he's on fire

steam train
30-08-07, 09:15 AM
Well if i was South African i wouldn't be complaining about having to chose between Fourie and Ruan. I would pick Fourie at 9 and have Ruan on the bench where he can cover for 9, 10, 11 and 15. Both class players but Fourie is a better scrum half and Ruan has the curse of versatility.

jaco
17-09-07, 09:30 AM
Fourie du Preez!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
The Best!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Glorzifen
20-09-07, 03:00 AM
If old Joost isn't doing too much, I'm sure he'd love to come back and play a few games :D

*sigh*

I wish.

Fourie has to be first choice (did you see his PACE against England?!) Holy smokes.
And, as people have already mentioned...Ruan is useful on the bench because he can slot in anywhere.

jaco
20-09-07, 07:42 AM
They are playing Januarie this saterday before Pienaar?
I dont know what jake is thinking
Pienaar is surely the better scrummy

alvin136
04-10-07, 10:32 AM
Of course its Fourie, even ruan pienaar cant keep up with him yeah

percymontgomery
29-10-07, 07:26 AM
obviously du preez

Stoffel
08-11-07, 05:38 AM
Du Preez was player of the tournament, no?

lean.rs72
17-12-07, 07:24 PM
i think fourie du preez is the best scrumhalf of the world cup

Camp0
29-12-07, 07:32 AM
fourie du preez is the best.

Biltong Boer
09-01-08, 07:23 AM
It has to be de Preez as for Ruan we will have to see if he can shine 2 years in a row.

Usually South African stars have an promising rookie season great main season then flops the next year. I don't know if it is the presure or big heads but it seems to be a curse in SA rubgy.

What I am trying to say here is it is to early to compare a possible (Ruan) to somone that has proven himself for many years running.