Find TRF at:
RWC 2011 HB
Sidhe Rugby Challenge
Both
Especially for all the de-railers, here is a thread just for you. If you must behave like horrible schoolchildren, get your fanboisms out between the HB and Sidhe product here while letting the mature board users talk like adults.
Go nuts, but keep it in this thread.
WARNING!
The above comments may contain traces of sarcasm and/or humour
They also may not reflect the opinions of those who read them
Reader discretion is advised
I think both games are gonna be awesome, instead of one rugby game we are getting 2 in one year, I'm happy.
I think that people think that this rugby website forum is all about HB studios and not about sidhe, People tend not to realise that this is named The rugby forum, i think since hb got a forum section for their own then sidhe should because they make quality rugby games.
As for who is better, i dont really judge companies to be honest. I just hope they both try their best and produce some quality rugby time so i can play it on the xbox
I think that one game may be better or they'll be similar in quality.
If only that place were to exist, it would be fantastic. I would call the forum "Sidhe Games"Originally Posted by nato
I guess if this is the "Comparison Thread" then we should probably have something to compare... These are the recent screenshots that have been released from Sidhe and HB. The HB (RWC 2011) pictures are the larger ones.
IMO The pics of Rugby Challenge look a whole lot nicer... although i have a feeling that the RWC 2011 pics aren't the final product, i'm assuming it's a pretty stripped back version possibly missing some player detail and a ref
I like the graphics for rugby challenge esp. the stadium and the people. just a matter of whether the players/gameplay will be any good. RWC 2011 screenshot looks a bit like '08 but I hope its just a beta screenshot from the game.
Hey you guys like the look of these: http://rugbychallengegame.com/2011/0...n-screenshots/
Rugby Challenge looks amazing.
http://i273.photobucket.com/albums/j.../Woldogsig.png
http://img100.imageshack.us/img100/8637/redsws2.png
There is not enough darkness in all the world to put out the light of even one small candle
Rugby Challenge is looking Amazing!!! the graphics could give Fifa a run for their money!!! Haha! Can't wait to see it in action!
I think there might be a few more 'Sidhe fanboys' after this.
Can you blame them...?
No you can't those screens are amazing
Soon we shall rejoice
http://kidneyclock.net/
Nope, especially considering I joined the Sidhe fan club quite a while ago
Wow; now that are the Visuals i was expecting from HB's game since they don't have many licenses; but now it seems Rugby Challenge have more Licenses and way better Graphics/Visuals...now we just have to wait for the Gameplay.
http://a4.l3-images.myspacecdn.com/i...22ee37cf/l.jpg
Nkosi Sikelel' iAfrika, Sharks 4 Eva, Love them or Fear them, my Blood is Green and Gold, Black and White and Go HB Studios and 505 Games!!
Wow.. Those new screenshots of the onfield action by Sidhe are just. Wow.. Breathtaking..
They have ticked a few more boxes.. all thats left is the Gameplay...
Rugby Challenge Screenshots here
CLICK ON LINK BELOW!!!!!
http://rugbychallengegame.com/2011/0.../#comment-3034
Wow their good, still no shots of the gameplay angle but from them we needn't worry. On pitch ref as well. I can't wait for either of these games.
"Sexton"
"Out to O'Driscoll"
"O'Driscoll around Davies, He's wrong footed Cuthbert"
"ZEEEEEEEEEEEEEEBBBBBBBBBOOOOOOOOOOOO"
The ref in the screenshot has an afro LOL ;p
rugby challenge looks like they have used the unreal engine that runs most shooter games... am I not far off here??? Could be rag doll physics then!!! :-)
also this is brilliant news in the long run guys, i predicted that we may have our own pro evo v fifa war soon... ummm what does this look like???! Sidhe have got the graphics... HB might have the gameplay... might be getting a title a year, with hb and sidhe alternating, trying to out perform the other company... this could be awesome awesome!
looking at the pics, its almost embarrassing how much better rugby challenge looks.
BUT, there are a bunch of games out there that look cracking and the gameplay doesnt match up (I think most of us would take gameplay over looks in the long run?), so I think I'm going to wait and see some in game action to make my mind up.
But those photos do look pretty amazing...
If it aint broke, you're probably not trying hard enough.
I read somewhere that Hb studios had a really small budget to work with ?? I just wonder how big was Sidhe budget ? I guess the images that have been release kinda says it all.
I couldnt help but smile looking at the rugby challenge screens, they look epic. I hope for HB's sake they have got an ace up their sleeve in the graphics department; but what I care most about is which game actually plays and feels most like rugby - that's the clincher for me.
looking impressive so far whats the story with non super league club teams will they be included sorry if this has already being asked
It's a union game. Superleague is League.
"Sexton"
"Out to O'Driscoll"
"O'Driscoll around Davies, He's wrong footed Cuthbert"
"ZEEEEEEEEEEEEEEBBBBBBBBBOOOOOOOOOOOO"
Absoloutley awesome realism from the sidhe screenshots, was expecting it to be the other way around if im honest. The only things I would criticise them on (if you can call it criticising) is in the pictures alot of the boots look the same and the scrum looks very stable and controlled. Having said that if you took a picture of a scrum it would appear stable, its only watching the scrum you realise its like two 900kg bulls smashing into eachother :P Absoloutley epic overall from Sidhe. Now to compare them with the 'exclusive first images' from HB...
sidhe have said the screenshots are from three weeks ago and it's all been changed now.
No, he didn't. He said that tattoos had been added to Sonny Bill and he said that two glitches were sorted. He didn't say anything about boots.
sorry you are right i miss read one of the things he had said
Reply With Quote
