View Poll Results: RWC 11 or Sidhe Rugby Challenge ?

Voters
778. You may not vote on this poll
  • RWC 2011 HB

    81 10.41%
  • Sidhe Rugby Challenge

    418 53.73%
  • Both

    279 35.86%

The comparison thread

   
Page 3 of 21 FirstFirst 1234513 ... LastLast
  1. #61
    Junior Member

    • Ireland
    • 7 posts
    • Joined: Sep 2010
    • From: Cork
    Munster
    Quote Originally Posted by grantyboyh14 View Post
    are you sure your not looking at the hb screenshots
    Ha,no def Sidhes!!Hbs look ****e but fingers cross it wont reflect them!!Getn both anyway,making up for the past 3 years without buyin 1 :P

  2. # ADS
    Circuit advertisement
    Join Date
    Always
    Location
    Advertising world
    Posts
    Many
     

  3. #62
    Junior Member

    • Argentina
    • 24 posts
    • Joined: Jul 2009
    • From: Argentina - Buenos Aires
    Banco
    Quote Originally Posted by Munster9 View Post
    Ha,no def Sidhes!!Hbs look ****e but fingers cross it wont reflect them!!Getn both anyway,making up for the past 3 years without buyin 1 :P
    that's right...why only one when I can buy both and then choose...he!
    Banco Nacion - URBA - Argentina

  4. #63
    Junior Member

    • Ireland
    • 8 posts
    • Joined: Jun 2011
    Munster
    rugby challenge looks phenomenal

  5. #64
    Junior Member

    • Australia
    • 7 posts
    • Joined: Apr 2010
    • From: Australia
    Reds
    South Africa teams, International and Super Rugby, aren't in the game.
    Last edited by Ducky97; 20-06-11 at 08:04 AM. Reason: spelling

  6. #65
    Member

    mattday1986's Avatar
    • England
    • 87 posts
    • Joined: Feb 2009
    • From: London
    Quote Originally Posted by Klaskaptein View Post
    does anybdy know if ths rugby challenge game will be released in south africa..? Really hope sow...
    SANZAR have let you down I'm afraid

  7. #66
    Senior Member

    Milla's Avatar
    • New Zealand
    • 207 posts
    • Joined: Sep 2010
    • From: New Zealand
    The chances of release in RSA are still well alive. HES are hard at work on sorting out distribution there.

  8. #67
    Senior Member

    cmac95's Avatar
    • Ireland
    • 2,160 posts
    • Joined: Dec 2010
    • From: Dublin
    Leinster
    I don't know if it's already been asked but will it be released in Ireland? I guess it will be seen as it's going to be released in the U.K and if not I'll just order it on amazon anyway.
    "Sexton"
    "Out to O'Driscoll"
    "O'Driscoll around Davies, He's wrong footed Cuthbert"
    "ZEEEEEEEEEEEEEEBBBBBBBBBOOOOOOOOOOOO"

  9. #68
    Senior Member

    TVH11's Avatar
    • Wales
    • 1,059 posts
    • Joined: Apr 2007
    • From: Cardiff/Ammanford , South Wales
    Ospreys
    well regardless of whether either game has licences for certain countries, we're all gonna buy em anyways. Its like Fifa doesn't have wales (at all) but it still sells in wales. so its gonna be fine lets sit tight and enjoy the ride woop woop
    You can take the boy out of the Amman Valley, but you can't take the Amman Valley outta the boy

  10. #69
    Senior Member

    Milla's Avatar
    • New Zealand
    • 207 posts
    • Joined: Sep 2010
    • From: New Zealand
    Quote Originally Posted by cmac95 View Post
    I don't know if it's already been asked but will it be released in Ireland? I guess it will be seen as it's going to be released in the U.K and if not I'll just order it on amazon anyway.
    NZ, Australia, France, and the UK are finalised. HES are still working on the rest. We'll keep everyone up-to-date as we can, but at worst you can order it from the UK.

  11. #70
    Junior Member

    • 9 posts
    • Joined: Apr 2010
    Force
    Quote Originally Posted by TRF_Olyy View Post
    As this is the comparison thread, I'm going to compare nicknames:
    Rugby World Cup 2011 = RWC11, RWC2011, World Cup, Rugby World Cup, Rugby 11

    Rugby Challenge = Rugga Chugga.
    I really hate the name "Rugga Chugga"

    I like "Rugby Challenge" but "Rugga Chugga"
    Urghh


    RWC: 1
    Rugby Challenge: 0
    lame

  12. #71
    Senior Member

    • South Africa
    • 118 posts
    • Joined: Apr 2011
    South Africa
    Ok just to be clear, are South Africa in this game? Like all the licensed players and jerseys and such? Because i know they are NOT in the Rugby Challenge game. Also will this game have the Super 15?

  13. #72
    Senior Member

    TheBokke's Avatar
    • South Africa
    • 116 posts
    • Joined: Jan 2005
    South Africa
    Peanut bru where have you been. South Africa will be in the game however if they are licensed is still to be announced. Super 15- NO for the 100th time on this and the Sidhe forums. HES(Sidhe- Rugby Challenge) have obtained the super 15 license, but it will not include Saffa teams.
    Disclaimer for this You Tube link: You would be Smart not to view this link it could drive you Cooky: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pdr-W775hk4

  14. #73
    Senior Member

    • South Africa
    • 118 posts
    • Joined: Apr 2011
    South Africa
    Quote Originally Posted by TheBokke View Post
    Peanut bru where have you been. South Africa will be in the game however if they are licensed is still to be announced. Super 15- NO for the 100th time on this and the Sidhe forums. HES(Sidhe- Rugby Challenge) have obtained the super 15 license, but it will not include Saffa teams.
    Haha been away mate. But seriously we better be licensed mate, we need atleast one game where the Boks can be represented. Sidhe should not even make the Super 15 anymore then, what is the point if SA teams are not there? Super 10? It's sad though because it seems as if Sidhe have the better graphics...both game by the looks of it already have their flaws...and they have not even been released yet. Gotta have faith i guess.

  15. #74
    Senior Member

    osulli mi's Avatar
    • Ireland
    • 1,015 posts
    • Joined: Apr 2011
    • From: Dublin
    Munster
    i think the SA super 15 teams are in it but the curries cup isnt
    "Shhh quiet lads , its the immature baby dicked turnip munching infant."

  16. #75
    Junior Member

    Glenfillan's Avatar
    • South Africa
    • 27 posts
    • Joined: May 2010
    Bulls
    Quote Originally Posted by osulli mi View Post
    i think the SA super 15 teams are in it but the curries cup isnt
    No mate, not a single SA team will feature in RC. So if RWC does not get the Licensing for the Springboks there will be no SA representaion in any game.

  17. #76
    Senior Member

    osulli mi's Avatar
    • Ireland
    • 1,015 posts
    • Joined: Apr 2011
    • From: Dublin
    Munster
    yea just saw that **** one
    "Shhh quiet lads , its the immature baby dicked turnip munching infant."

  18. #77
    Senior Member

    Wally's Avatar
    • 321 posts
    • Joined: May 2004
    • From: Brisbane, Australia
    Quote Originally Posted by Glenfillan View Post
    No mate, not a single SA team will feature in RC. So if RWC does not get the Licensing for the Springboks there will be no SA representaion in any game.
    There will be South African teams they just won't be licensed.

  19. #78
    Member

    • 36 posts
    • Joined: Dec 2010
    Quote Originally Posted by peanuts40 View Post
    Haha been away mate. But seriously we better be licensed mate, we need atleast one game where the Boks can be represented. Sidhe should not even make the Super 15 anymore then, what is the point if SA teams are not there? Super 10? It's sad though because it seems as if Sidhe have the better graphics...both game by the looks of it already have their flaws...and they have not even been released yet. Gotta have faith i guess.
    Youre crazy. Offcourse Sidhe will continue to include the Super rugby mode in RC! Just because South African Rugby and its members are unable to come to an agreement with HES regarding licensing dosent mean that Sidhe should make half a game! The SA teams will be generic with the ability to EDIT.

    The Rugby world has lived without SA Rugby before and now it seems the gaming community will have to aswell due to backwards thinking. Pity but there is only one Country's Union to blame for this mess. If you dont like it I suggest you petition the SA Rugby Union as I and many others have.

  20. #79
    Junior Member

    • South Africa
    • 2 posts
    • Joined: Jun 2011
    Stormers
    Quote Originally Posted by joydivision1979 View Post
    Youre crazy. Offcourse Sidhe will continue to include the Super rugby mode in RC! Just because South African Rugby and its members are unable to come to an agreement with HES regarding licensing dosent mean that Sidhe should make half a game! The SA teams will be generic with the ability to EDIT.

    The Rugby world has lived without SA Rugby before and now it seems the gaming community will have to aswell due to backwards thinking. Pity but there is only one Country's Union to blame for this mess. If you dont like it I suggest you petition the SA Rugby Union as I and many others have.
    England are also RWC11 Exclusive. You come across as an uber asshole, but I have to agree with you, all this licensing here, and there has ruined the pick up and play potential for most guys who dont want to spend hours reconfiguring the unlicensed sides on both sides of the fence. Its really ****** me off. Competition should ensure higher quality games as both sides jostle to produce the better game, but all I've seen from these two developers are (mostly not even ingame) screenshots. I get the sense that rather than trying to make $$$ by producing the best quality game, they are both just sitting back and hoping to dupe as many rugby fans into buying their particular game.

    Lets face it, we are all here because we love the game, and its great that we get 2 games in 1 year, but I am disappointed in both developers for the negative tactics that have been employed by HB and Sihde, and would loved to have a complete game, that included the clubs as well. Back to playing Jonah Lomu Rugby for me. McCabe of the Rage Allstars was the best!!!!

    /rant over
    Last edited by PiXeL_NiNja; 23-06-11 at 11:16 AM.

  21. #80
    Junior Member

    • 28 posts
    • Joined: Apr 2010
    have you guys seen this?? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BGJZLoi9H2A

    :O

  22. #81
    Member

    • Australia
    • 75 posts
    • Joined: May 2010
    Waratahs
    Wallabies rugby challenge for win baby, customer feedback has been fantastic, graphics are awesome, Morpheme gaming engine has been used, Jonah Lomu licensed, All Blacks and Wallabies licensed, Super rugby licensed, aviva premiership, itm cup, and 95 teams in total, as well as the ability to create hundreds of teams. Also, having added Unique Mario and Milla characters is pure awesomeness. Bring on September!

  23. #82
    Junior Member

    • 28 posts
    • Joined: Apr 2010
    Quote Originally Posted by lewis1234 View Post
    Wallabies rugby challenge for win baby, customer feedback has been fantastic, graphics are awesome, Morpheme gaming engine has been used, Jonah Lomu licensed, All Blacks and Wallabies licensed, Super rugby licensed, aviva premiership, itm cup, and 95 teams in total, as well as the ability to create hundreds of teams. Also, having added Unique Mario and Milla characters is pure awesomeness. Bring on September!
    Didnt know they'd used the morpheme engine, that's sick. I can't wait for both gamessssssssssssss ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh hhrghghr. Need to see some gameplay footage

  24. #83
    Dual-Coder

    TRF_Olyy's Avatar
    • England
    • 16,480 posts
    • Joined: Apr 2008
    • From: Sunny old England
    Sale
    Morpheme is not a physics engine, it's an animation engine - not the same as backbreaker

  25. #84
    Junior Member

    PunchingCam1000's Avatar
    • Scotland
    • 10 posts
    • Joined: Jun 2011
    • From: Leicester
    Leicester
    People forget that there is newer screen shots of RWC11 on some of the forums, I would give them a look before actually making a major decision on which game is better,

    To be honest, both look good ebough for no rugby games on this generation of console

  26. #85
    TRF Legend

    • England
    • 7,894 posts
    • Joined: Feb 2005
    • From: Northampton, England
    Northampton
    Quote Originally Posted by PunchingCam1000 View Post
    People forget that there is newer screen shots of RWC11 on some of the forums, I would give them a look before actually making a major decision on which game is better,

    To be honest, both look good ebough for no rugby games on this generation of console
    Do you mean TRF forums, or other websites?

    WARNING!
    The above comments may contain traces of sarcasm and/or humour
    They also may not reflect the opinions of those who read them
    Reader discretion is advised

  27. #86
    Member

    • Australia
    • 75 posts
    • Joined: May 2010
    Waratahs
    Quote Originally Posted by TRF_Olyy View Post
    Morpheme is not a physics engine, it's an animation engine - not the same as backbreaker
    So has RWC 2011 used it?

  28. #87
    Dual-Coder

    TRF_Olyy's Avatar
    • England
    • 16,480 posts
    • Joined: Apr 2008
    • From: Sunny old England
    Sale
    No, but please point out where I said it did...
    I was just saying that, as a lot of people get the two confused as they're both produced by Natural Motion

  29. #88
    Senior Member

    lance2010's Avatar
    • New Zealand
    • 372 posts
    • Joined: May 2010
    • From: Te Puke,NZ
    Blues
    I'm sure both Rugby titles we be mind blowing,I wont be buying RWC2011 due to the fact i don't play online so a game with 20 internationals doesn't appeal to me.I will be buying All Blacks RC from E.B games retailing at $129.99 NZ dollars.RC provides me with a whole lot more in terms of longevity as i don't play online.
    I will however hire RWC2011 to play from the local video store.
    You can do no wrong in doing right,You can do no right in doing wrong.

  30. #89
    Senior Member

    formerlyfastwing's Avatar
    • Canada
    • 467 posts
    • Joined: Jun 2011
    Canada
    i will buy both, i have been waiting a very very long time for a rugby game to be released here in God's Country

    (oh man one of then better have a N/A release)

  31. #90
    Senior Member

    Mario's Avatar
    • 224 posts
    • Joined: Jun 2004
    Quote Originally Posted by PiXeL_NiNja View Post
    Lets face it, we are all here because we love the game, and its great that we get 2 games in 1 year, but I am disappointed in both developers for the negative tactics that have been employed by HB and Sidhe, and would loved to have a complete game, that included the clubs as well.
    I'm not sure what negative tactics you are suggesting we have engaged in.

Page 3 of 21 FirstFirst 1234513 ... LastLast