By sticking him in with the other three you are rating him along with the other three. When I said he was solidish, I refer to a few wee shakey moments scattered across the match. That is not the same as struggling - which would be at a much more dire level. Repeated mistakes causing significant problems within a short time period would be struggled at times. Repeated similar mistakes causing significant problems over a long time period would be struggled with X, Y or Z. Which is a far cry from what we seen yesterday.