Menu
Forums
New posts
Search forums
What's new
New posts
Latest activity
Log in
Register
What's new
Search
Search
Search titles and first posts only
Search titles only
By:
New posts
Search forums
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Help Support The Rugby Forum :
Forums
Rugby Union
International Test Matches
All Blacks 2021-2023 Thread
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Reply to thread
Message
<blockquote data-quote="Umaga&#039;s Witness" data-source="post: 1042902" data-attributes="member: 65365"><p>Fair points. Who do you pick instead?</p><p></p><p>I would agree that there are a few more complete players than ione for 13. But Riekos defence has improved, is pretty good, and he has x factor on his side. He was first in a couple if stats for the comp (for midfielders maybe, cant remember) and 4th in another one (im not much of a believer in relying on stats but they can say something). Hell definitely make the squad and its hard to see him not starting to be honest.</p><p></p><p>without caleb clarke or laumape they might be looking for someone with brute force, so i think theyll pick leicester as an option for 11 or 12. I agree hes not really ready, but he has performed in big games (which means a lot to the selectors) and they might feel now is their best opportunity to look to the future.</p><p></p><p>at 13 i think you need someone who has been playing there, so ione, ennor, or proctor, potentially PUJ. For 12, maybe its not quite as critical to have someone that been playing there a lot, so that brings options like leicester or jordie or PUJ. theyll pick havili ahead of all those, but theyll want a second option in the squad.</p><p></p><p><strong>props will be interesring too</strong></p><p></p><p>Unfortunately at the moment our best scrummaging props are the worst around the field and vice versa.</p><p>Apart from nepo joe and ofa, but perhaps the latter two will be unavailable due to injury?</p><p>Out of what is left,</p><p>at tighthead the best scrummagers are sione mafileo, tamaiti williams. Its unfortunate that two super franchises have overseas players as starting tighthead props, meaning we dont have a lot of experienced options. I think theyll bring back taavao, hes scrummaged well for the most part and is good around the field. Maybe they just let bower cover tighthead and dont pick any others. Renata might be an option. Fidow is good around the field but not so good in the scrum. Lomax hasnt been as good at scrum time this year but is a well balanced player so probably becomes option 3.</p><p></p><p>at loosehead, we have karl and bower. Hodgman made it last year but im not convinced with his scrummaging. Aidan ross or ethan de groot might get a chance. Numia is the best around the field but scrummaging not so good. Reuben oneill is an outside chance. Rakete stones is a great scrummager but inexperienced and not so good aroind the field</p><p></p><p> im guessing</p><p>Karl, bower, numia (project player)</p><p>Nepo, taavao, lomax</p></blockquote><p></p>
[QUOTE="Umaga's Witness, post: 1042902, member: 65365"] Fair points. Who do you pick instead? I would agree that there are a few more complete players than ione for 13. But Riekos defence has improved, is pretty good, and he has x factor on his side. He was first in a couple if stats for the comp (for midfielders maybe, cant remember) and 4th in another one (im not much of a believer in relying on stats but they can say something). Hell definitely make the squad and its hard to see him not starting to be honest. without caleb clarke or laumape they might be looking for someone with brute force, so i think theyll pick leicester as an option for 11 or 12. I agree hes not really ready, but he has performed in big games (which means a lot to the selectors) and they might feel now is their best opportunity to look to the future. at 13 i think you need someone who has been playing there, so ione, ennor, or proctor, potentially PUJ. For 12, maybe its not quite as critical to have someone that been playing there a lot, so that brings options like leicester or jordie or PUJ. theyll pick havili ahead of all those, but theyll want a second option in the squad. [B]props will be interesring too[/B] Unfortunately at the moment our best scrummaging props are the worst around the field and vice versa. Apart from nepo joe and ofa, but perhaps the latter two will be unavailable due to injury? Out of what is left, at tighthead the best scrummagers are sione mafileo, tamaiti williams. Its unfortunate that two super franchises have overseas players as starting tighthead props, meaning we dont have a lot of experienced options. I think theyll bring back taavao, hes scrummaged well for the most part and is good around the field. Maybe they just let bower cover tighthead and dont pick any others. Renata might be an option. Fidow is good around the field but not so good in the scrum. Lomax hasnt been as good at scrum time this year but is a well balanced player so probably becomes option 3. at loosehead, we have karl and bower. Hodgman made it last year but im not convinced with his scrummaging. Aidan ross or ethan de groot might get a chance. Numia is the best around the field but scrummaging not so good. Reuben oneill is an outside chance. Rakete stones is a great scrummager but inexperienced and not so good aroind the field im guessing Karl, bower, numia (project player) Nepo, taavao, lomax [/QUOTE]
Verification
Post reply
Forums
Rugby Union
International Test Matches
All Blacks 2021-2023 Thread
Top