Another yellow at the maul? Possibly.
-
Help Support The Rugby Forum :
[Challenge Cup 2018] Final - Cardiff Blues vs Gloucester
- Thread starter Thingimubob
- Start date
I miss Scully. 
- Joined
- Nov 13, 2014
- Messages
- 5,586
- Reaction score
- 2,956
If it is, Garces deserves dropping from all reffin.
He has had a really bad game. No doubting the yellow, but a second after he caused a 14 point swing in the game shouldn’t be allowed.
- Joined
- Nov 13, 2014
- Messages
- 5,586
- Reaction score
- 2,956
I thought you had to let them up?
Edit: no doubting the Blue’s heart, but Garces should get motm.
Edit: no doubting the Blue’s heart, but Garces should get motm.
- Joined
- Aug 18, 2015
- Messages
- 10,366
- Reaction score
- 5,994
WTF was Braley doing, just clear them out.
Gloucester doing gloucester things.
No wonder Ackerman wants to basically have his lions team.
No wonder Ackerman wants to basically have his lions team.
- Joined
- Aug 18, 2015
- Messages
- 10,366
- Reaction score
- 5,994
Blues fought back fantastically in the second half, but Gloucester were robbed there by the ref. Simple fact is Blues got a try that was clearly offside.
Gloucester you bunch of muppets. Wow.
Credit to Cardiff.
Credit to Cardiff.
Mental ending to the game,
Great cup final though, there's always the risk the teams go in trying not to lose rather than trying to win
Great cup final though, there's always the risk the teams go in trying not to lose rather than trying to win
- Joined
- Nov 13, 2014
- Messages
- 5,586
- Reaction score
- 2,956
Also the try in the first half wrongly disallowed.
I miss Scully.
USA!!!! USA!!!!
- Joined
- Aug 18, 2015
- Messages
- 10,366
- Reaction score
- 5,994
Yeah though that I can see as a honest mistake and just annoying he didn't check. However asking the TMO to check and then not seeing it's offside is just incompetence. It's times like this when I'd love to be in the post match analysis to see if they are actually called on it, because if they get that wrong they shouldn't be officiating at club level let alone european/international.
Come on now BT you can do better than that. Don’t address them as European champions.
What a game. Superb 2nd half from Cardiff. Big Nick is a hero
Great game of rugby. Fair play to both sides for putting on a great show.
Both sides looked very good in patches, with Gloucester possessing a few more physical beasts, and Blues a few more x-factor players behind.
I can understand the criticism of the ref from Gloucester supporters though. Definite try disallowed in the first half, why not let the try be scored then check with the tmo instead of making a split second decision? Tomos Williams didn't look offside to me? Still that first half decision was a big one, although shouldn't take away from Blues because Gloucester were still way in front at half time.
Both sides looked very good in patches, with Gloucester possessing a few more physical beasts, and Blues a few more x-factor players behind.
I can understand the criticism of the ref from Gloucester supporters though. Definite try disallowed in the first half, why not let the try be scored then check with the tmo instead of making a split second decision? Tomos Williams didn't look offside to me? Still that first half decision was a big one, although shouldn't take away from Blues because Gloucester were still way in front at half time.
A hell of a lot of crowing from Welsh rugby fans on social media considering the 14pt swing caused by incompetent refereeing.
Bit embarrassing
*I should note that Gloucester are my least favourite club, and I wanted Cardiff to win, before I get called a bitter Englishman
Double edit: I'm not on about Cardiff fans celebrating the win, but the hoards of troglodytes using the result to have a pop at the English. They should be having a pop at SANZAR from the make up of the Gloucester side!
Bit embarrassing
*I should note that Gloucester are my least favourite club, and I wanted Cardiff to win, before I get called a bitter Englishman
Double edit: I'm not on about Cardiff fans celebrating the win, but the hoards of troglodytes using the result to have a pop at the English. They should be having a pop at SANZAR from the make up of the Gloucester side!
Last edited:
- Joined
- Aug 18, 2015
- Messages
- 10,366
- Reaction score
- 5,994
Yeah, didn't look offside cause they didn't actually show a decent angle more than once. At this stage I would want clear proof it wasn't because based on what I saw during the TMO it wasn't even close.
Had a propper look at the Garyn Smith (Not Tomos Williams) try in post match, and all the pundits agreed he wasn't offside, flat but not offside. So not a 14 point swing.
Obviously there's still the matter of the disallowed try in the first half, which was poor; but a team can't pit it all on the ref when the decision was early in the second quarter and they still went in at half time 14 points up!
Obviously there's still the matter of the disallowed try in the first half, which was poor; but a team can't pit it all on the ref when the decision was early in the second quarter and they still went in at half time 14 points up!
Last edited:
