Jimmy Cowan the best AB Halfback come world cup?

Discussion in 'General Rugby Union' started by cwans, Sep 30, 2006.

  1. cwans

    cwans Guest

    Some interesting interview from the GREAT jon preston...

    Cowan first-choice No 9 for Preston
    29 September 2006
    By DARYL HOLDEN

    Former All Black Jon Preston has spiced up the halfback debate, saying Southland's Jimmy Cowan has the best pass in the country and could be the World Cup test starter next year.

    Cowan has been ranked No 3 in the All Blacks' setup this season, behind Byron Kelleher and Piri Weepu, and some critics think the Stags' halfback will struggle to retain his national team spot.

    However, former New Zealand halfback Preston is a Cowan fan because of his rapidly improving, rocket-like pass.

    Cowan especially caught Preston's eye in his first test match start for the All Blacks, in the close loss to South Africa in Rustenburg three weeks ago, and then again in his return to the domestic scene in the Stags' Air New Zealand Cup repechage win over Taranaki last week.

    "I was really impressed with his display in the test match in South Africa, I must say, principally with his delivery of the ball off the deck," said Preston, who played 10 tests and 27 games for the All Blacks at halfback and first five-eighth from 1991 to 1997.

    "For my mind, I don't think the clearance has been a particularly strong area of New Zealand halfback play in recent times. There's a lot of strong halfbacks around; some big, powerful men and there's some good runners around but I think we've been perhaps lacking with decision-making and the speed of the clearance but I thought Jimmy Cowan displayed all that in a number of instances in that test match, in particular. "The other thing about him that I like is that he does a bit of everything.

    He is quite a big, strong halfback and, to a degree, I think you have to be like that at test level these days.

    "He's also got a high workrate.

    You see him pull of a lot of crucial covering tackles and he still has a kicking game.

    "So there's all these sort of skills to his game."

    Preston believes Cowan's option taking and running has also improved but it was his crisp passing that impressed in the South African test, being a step up from the delivery of Kelleher and Weepu.

    Preston liked Cowan's limited movement and speed in clearing the ball from the ground.

    "He also has the speed through the air and good length on his pass," said Preston, who works as a rugby comments person for Sky TV.

    "I think I commented during a recent game that he gave Dan Carter just a split second extra time in that South African test.

    "And the way defences are these days – most of them are offside to start with – they rush up and put massive pressure on inside backs and try and shut down their time and space.

    "So any (extra) split second makes a big difference." For all that, Preston thinks Weepu "probably" had the ability to be the best halfback in New Zealand but his up and down form was a worry.

    So Preston sees no reason 24-year-old Cowan can't continue to improve and be the All Blacks' first-choice halfback by the World Cup next year.

    However, Preston is also a fan of Canterbury's Andrew Ellis because, like Cowan, he has a good pass. He would love to see both Ellis and Cowan selected for the All Blacks' end-of-year tour.

    "Just because I don't think they're going to see any more out of the other two (Weepu and Kelleher)," Preston said.

    "I think they pretty much know what they're going to get from them."


    Taken from Stuff.co.nz

    If you were Henry and you were choosing your ranking for best 3 halfbacks... who would they be?

    I'd be inclined to go:

    Cowan
    Ellis
    Weepu

    Cowan and Ellis for speed of pass for Carter... Weepu for his composure.
     
  2. Forum Ad Advertisement

  3. ..::ERIC::..

    ..::ERIC::.. Guest

    I'd stick to the current 3. Weepu, Kelleher, Cowan.
     
  4. nez

    nez Guest

    i think it's depending on what exactly henry will want, the physicality of weepu/kelleher or the quick clearance of cowan and ellis.
     
  5. shiznit

    shiznit Guest

    anyone would think kelleher and weepu dont pass it quick enough....?? i dont know what preston is on about...compared to justin marshall weepu and kelleher are shotguns.

    cowan shouldnt be allowed anywhere near an all blacks jearsey. i will tell you why he gets the ball cleared quickly... he doesnt look where he passes thats why... for the 'extra split second' he gave carter in that south african test we bloody lost... i will stick with weepu and kelleher thank you very much. for a 3rd string it would be between Cowan, Ellis & the 2 Otago halfbacks.
     
  6. ShowMe

    ShowMe Guest

    Bring back marshall! seriously he'd waltz straight back into the black jersey if he came back, i admit he may not have the bullet passing like weepu and co. but he has 'big game' temperament and not to mention experience the allblacks will need in a world cup campaign.
    Yall are throwing ellis name around like hes established, he needs to prove himself in the black jersey first, so will be interesting to see if he gets picked and played on the end of year tour.
    Never been a big fan of cowan....or jon preston. They both lack/ed the same thing...xfactor.
     
  7. esoj

    esoj Guest

    cowan is not that great really and he makes the wrong decisions sometimes. weepu and kelleher take better options and have better all round skills. ellis looks very promising and i would have him in the squad over cowan any day of the week.

    marshall had his chance and went for the money overseas. his attidude has not been great and I don't think he would fit that well in the current ab's set up.
     
  8. ghettodan

    ghettodan Guest

    cowan sux..... only reason hes in there is cos he looks like marshall....
     
  9. dobrien7

    dobrien7 Guest

    Personally Cowan has one of the better, quicker passes around, now that he doesn't walk with the ball then pass. That 60min v SA in last test was some of the best service Carter has had all year... but do agree that he makes dumb decisions at times.
     
  10. weasel5000

    weasel5000 Guest

    Kelleher will be the starting halfback come the world cup. Whilst the other nines playing in New Zealand do offer their own unique strengths, Kelleher is the only one with a consistent all round game. His clearance both passing and kicking combined are better than any half in the New Zealand game, his sniping around the fringes and his rugged physicality at the breakdown is equal to that of Weepu's. His experience (45 tests, 22 as replacement) is another factor working to his advantage.

    For the other halfback's Weepu is a good viable option however I just feel as if he lacks temperament at times and would be more suited as a sixtieth minute impact replacement due to his running game. Good to have Cowan and Ellis waiting in the wings, I think both could do the job themselves.

    At the end of the day, all four halfbacks are interesting in their own way and you can only be pleased with the dilemma of who not to include
     
  11. Caledfwlch

    Caledfwlch Guest

    i always thought that byron was the one with the temper
     
Enjoyed this thread? Register to post your reply - click here!

Share This Page