• Help Support The Rugby Forum :

Most Important Position

Most Important Position on a rugby team

  • Locks

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • FLANKERS

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • No.8

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • lil Halfbacks

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Flyhalf

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Centres

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Wings

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Fullbacks

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    2
A

allblacksfreak

Guest
Here it is ladies and gentlemen... after some tough discussions over at a gay kicker's thread... I think its best for the whole TRF to give their point of view...
DECIDE NOW!!!
 
1

187

Guest
you can't really have a "most important position" in rugby in my view because it's a team sport. u can only have leaders. i chose 1st 5 though because they are generally known as the directors of a game.
 
R

Rugby_Cymru

Guest
I think it's clearly obvious here, that the unsung heroes of the team - and without a doubt the most important players - are the wingers.

Why has nobody vioted them yet?
:p
 
N

nez

Guest
agree with 187 cause it is a team sport. But in all honestly most rugby games start up front. That's why i picked props...remember this is coming from a guy that's played most of his rugby from fullback.
 
A

ALLBLACKS

Guest
1st 5 8th We definately are the most crucial, Everyone is important and needs to do there Job, But 1st 5's have to read the game we determine where the game is played and we are the masterminds of the game...The Generals. Rugby is a team sport though, everyone needs to do there Job.
 
B

Bullitt

Guest
A fly half is nothing without a scrum half. A scrum half is nothing without a pack. The pack cannot gat anywhere alone so need the wingers. The wingers cannot be fed without the centres. The centres never get the ball without the outside half.

No one is more important than another. Anyone who says otherwise is a <strike>communist</strike> f***ing moron.
 
C

Canadian_Rugby_Guy

Guest
well if you had your choice to make one player amazing at everything, which position would that be at? I say it's either at 10 or in the back row positions. Those are probably the positions where you need to be the most mobile and skilled to play.
 
M

melon

Guest
Use your brains. The answer is clearly the props. Anyone can play in the back line (i admit most people would do a **** job, but still they could do it), anyone can play flanker/#8 and second row, hooker is a bit more specialised. BUT! In a proper, contested scrum, there are only a select few in every team that can play the position of prop, properly.
 
S

sanzar

Guest
There is no position that is more 'important' than another, as a couple of the boys said, a rugby team needs both the forwards and backs functioning as a cohesive unit for them to be successful. That said, I picked the 10 simply because, along with 9, they bind the 2 forces together.
 
S

sambãd5

Guest
the only way imo where you could say a position is better than another is when you group them. then i can confidently say that the tight 5 combo is the most important. saying this i mean, when you see a team with a f***ing awesome tight five vs a team with a **** tight five the diffrence in quallity of play is at the greatest point compared to other groupings, such as loosies, inside/outside backs etc.
 
R

RoyalBlueStuey

Guest
I always think a good scrum half and fullback are vital to attack and defence respectively.
 
G

Gulli

Guest
evryone just as good if they give me decent ball at fullback if not then they are all rubbish :p
 
A

allblacksfreak

Guest
i shud have used a different question... lol.. but yeah it is very true that a rugby team needs all the players to work as a unit.. and without it, they will crumble.. Unity in Diversity... my favourite slogan that is... but still, the backs are gay...
 
R

RoyalBlueStuey

Guest
but still, the backs are gay...
[/b]

Waterloo's coach last year, Phil Winstanley, wrote a good piece that you might chuckle at :

“Before the game we had been given two separate changing rooms. As is usually the case the forwards and backs split. Believe me that I realised 1½ hours before kick-off I could do no more. As a coach you are always tempted to say a little bit more but on Saturday I could see that the forwards were more than in control and I resorted to spending my time stepping over hairdryers and make-up in the backs roomâ€

Still it might be worth pointing out that a bunch of smaller guys who have to go toe-to-toe with a bunch big, big guys deserve a bit of credit.
 
E

edinburgh_gunner

Guest
The front row are. We do the hard work in the scrum and retain the ball in open play.

All backs are gay.
 
E

el_tk

Guest
It's a team game but forwards are more important becuase they respect the ball more. We have to earn it so we don't waste it. You backs just carelessly lob it all over the place.
 
A

allblacksfreak

Guest
The Forward Pack

Eight handsome burly guys whom you'll gladly give your
beer and food to, and you'd want to marry your
daughter. They are intelligent, elegant, sensitive,
and sweet. Truly the ideal men.

The Backs

Seven guys who will steal your beer while you're not
looking, take advantage of your women folk, barnyard
animals, and all tubular household objects. Often dine
on quiche, brie cheese and wine. Been known to
understand the rule of the ESPN Extreme games' rules.
Regularly take blow dryers on road trips, wear bikini
underpants, and carry STDs (AVOID AT ALL COSTS).

Prop

Short but stout, these strapping men support the
hooker, but no money ever changes hands and the act is
never specificaly named.

Hooker

Often identified by a balding spot atop the head,
these vertically challenged but talented men stand
between the two props, and secures the ball for his
team during scrummages.

Second Row

These tall powerful men are the driving engines not
only the scrum, but of the entire game. They can be
found working their magic from deep in the scrum,
behind the front row, or lofting high above the line
outs pulling balls from the air.

The Back Row

Usually the most handsome and intelligent, these three
men of strength are often considered the renisance men
of the rugby field. They not only control the ball,
but the entire pitch. Remember, the back row defines
the whole team's style of play.

Scrumhalf

The point guard of the rugby team the scrumhalf
distributes the ball, runs hits, and kicks. Scrumhalf
is only half as handsome and burly as the pack members

Flyhalf

The first of those back guys, and the first of the
offensive chain. Often confused with an insect, may be
referred to as the man with "the foot."

Centers

Another pair of those back guys. Either power runner,
or annoying scampering guy usually found in the
opposite order, but whose main purpose is to get the
ball to ...

Wings

Ideally the fastest men on the team. Their job is to
"score with the ball", but they often confuse it with
"get tackled with the ball." Also an excellent snack
when smothered in hot sauce and deep fried.

Fullback

The last line of defense. A back even the pack can
appreciate, often viewed as a back row in the larval
stage
 
Top