Menu
Forums
New posts
Search forums
What's new
New posts
Latest activity
Log in
Register
What's new
Search
Search
Search titles and first posts only
Search titles only
By:
New posts
Search forums
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Help Support The Rugby Forum :
Forums
Rugby Union
International Test Matches
Spring Tour: New Zealand vs Ireland - 3rd Test. (23/6/2012, 07:35 GMT)
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Reply to thread
Message
<blockquote data-quote="Darwin" data-source="post: 513693" data-attributes="member: 24910"><p>Great ratings as always Nick - can't really disagree with any of them. I actually think it is a lot harder to give ratings after a total team performance like that, as the range between the top rated and bottom rated players is pretty small.</p><p></p><p>Overall I was incredibly impressed with the AB's performance. I expected them to have a massive game after last weeks disappointing effort, but I wasn't expecting them to be <em>that</em> dominant. We still weren't probably as dominant in the front-row as we may have hoped, but in general the front-row did their jobs. I'm starting to get a bit worried about Andrew Hore at times though, as he does seem to be showing his age. He's still incredibly hard working at the breakdown and does his core jobs well, but he was exposed a couple of times in defense due to his lack of pace. I've seen him exposed like this for the Highlanders a couple of times this season too - I don' think it is a major issue yet, but could become one if he loses any more pace. It was great to see Mealamu back, and he made a very good impact when he came on with his ball running - I wonder whether he or Hore will be the number 1 hooker during the Rugby Championship? Sam Whitelock was solid, but Luke Romano had an outstanding debut. He is an incredibly powerful ball runner (he ran through Cian Healy at one stage like he wasn't even there), and he was used very effectively by the AB's (often in midfield from a lineout). He will certainly have more challenging matches to come, but he made an incredibly promising debut, and more than justified his inclusion in the squad (hopefully this finally signals the end of Ali Williams!). </p><p></p><p>I thought the loose-forward trio as a combination was outstanding. Messam had his best game in a black jersey, which was great to see. The AB's selectors have told him to increase his physicality, and boy did he deliver! He was smashing people back in the tackle, and it was great to see him use his running game to good effect. He will be very difficult to leave out of the squad for the Rugby Championship after that performance, and he will certainly be putting the heat on Vito and Thomson for a starting spot at 6. McCaw looked far more like the McCaw of old this week. His handling was far better, and he made a couple of great steals at the breakdown. Probably the standout loosies for NZ was Sam Cane (again). He has a phenomenal work-rate - he just seems to do everything at full speed too. He hits hard in the tackle, and his running game is superb too - I questioned whether he was the 2nd best 7 in the country at the start of this series, but he's certainly gone a long way to dispel any doubts I previously had!</p><p></p><p>Smith was again superb at 9. I love the fact our backline now gets quick ball, and his sharpe running game is a real threat the base of the breakdown. He again proved that, despite his lack of size, he is more than able to hold his own in defense. My only (very slight) criticism is he over-kicked his box-kicks, but I suppose it is good to have things to work on! Cruden was quite frankly phenomenal in the 20-odds mins he was on the field. The AB's were going at over a point a minute, and Ireland didn't seem to have any idea how to stop Cruden. While it was disappointing he went off so early it was a great opportunity for Barrett, who had a strong debut. He wasn't as threatening as Cruden, but he was far from overawed, and took the ball to the line very well, generally took the right options, and importantly (as it has been a weakness of his) was rock-solid in defense. SBW had been well contained all series, but Ireland failed to contain him this match. Conrad Smith was again the unsung hero of the backline, making the right decisions every time both in attack and defense. Despite the big scoreline the outside backs didn't really get the ball in space that much, but all had good games. I was a bit worried when Gear stuffed up the first two high kicks but he recovered very well, and scored a great try. What really impressed me was the aggression he brought to he game - not only with ball in hand, but he was also smashing people in defense. Smith was solid on the right wing - his ability to seamlessly slot in anywhere in backline is a big asset, while Dagg too was solid at fullback (and made some massive punts).</p><p></p><p>Hard to identify many standouts for Ireland. Healy made a couple of good runs, but did miss a few tackles (he will want to forget Romano running straight through him). I was again impressed by Ryan - he was solid all round, and good at the lineout. I remain unconvinced by Touhy though - his work-rate doesn't impress me, and he made a few basic errors. O'Brien was probably the pick of the loosies again, but he is far from the devastating ball running that we were promised at the start of the series. He got driven back numerous times in the tackle, but he did do a good job of disrupting New Zealand's ball at the breakdown on a number of occasions. Can't name any standouts in the backs, though it is hard to stand out when your forwards are completely outplayed.</p><p></p><p>Overall I was delighted by the performance - bring on the Rugby Championship!</p></blockquote><p></p>
[QUOTE="Darwin, post: 513693, member: 24910"] Great ratings as always Nick - can't really disagree with any of them. I actually think it is a lot harder to give ratings after a total team performance like that, as the range between the top rated and bottom rated players is pretty small. Overall I was incredibly impressed with the AB's performance. I expected them to have a massive game after last weeks disappointing effort, but I wasn't expecting them to be [I]that[/I] dominant. We still weren't probably as dominant in the front-row as we may have hoped, but in general the front-row did their jobs. I'm starting to get a bit worried about Andrew Hore at times though, as he does seem to be showing his age. He's still incredibly hard working at the breakdown and does his core jobs well, but he was exposed a couple of times in defense due to his lack of pace. I've seen him exposed like this for the Highlanders a couple of times this season too - I don' think it is a major issue yet, but could become one if he loses any more pace. It was great to see Mealamu back, and he made a very good impact when he came on with his ball running - I wonder whether he or Hore will be the number 1 hooker during the Rugby Championship? Sam Whitelock was solid, but Luke Romano had an outstanding debut. He is an incredibly powerful ball runner (he ran through Cian Healy at one stage like he wasn't even there), and he was used very effectively by the AB's (often in midfield from a lineout). He will certainly have more challenging matches to come, but he made an incredibly promising debut, and more than justified his inclusion in the squad (hopefully this finally signals the end of Ali Williams!). I thought the loose-forward trio as a combination was outstanding. Messam had his best game in a black jersey, which was great to see. The AB's selectors have told him to increase his physicality, and boy did he deliver! He was smashing people back in the tackle, and it was great to see him use his running game to good effect. He will be very difficult to leave out of the squad for the Rugby Championship after that performance, and he will certainly be putting the heat on Vito and Thomson for a starting spot at 6. McCaw looked far more like the McCaw of old this week. His handling was far better, and he made a couple of great steals at the breakdown. Probably the standout loosies for NZ was Sam Cane (again). He has a phenomenal work-rate - he just seems to do everything at full speed too. He hits hard in the tackle, and his running game is superb too - I questioned whether he was the 2nd best 7 in the country at the start of this series, but he's certainly gone a long way to dispel any doubts I previously had! Smith was again superb at 9. I love the fact our backline now gets quick ball, and his sharpe running game is a real threat the base of the breakdown. He again proved that, despite his lack of size, he is more than able to hold his own in defense. My only (very slight) criticism is he over-kicked his box-kicks, but I suppose it is good to have things to work on! Cruden was quite frankly phenomenal in the 20-odds mins he was on the field. The AB's were going at over a point a minute, and Ireland didn't seem to have any idea how to stop Cruden. While it was disappointing he went off so early it was a great opportunity for Barrett, who had a strong debut. He wasn't as threatening as Cruden, but he was far from overawed, and took the ball to the line very well, generally took the right options, and importantly (as it has been a weakness of his) was rock-solid in defense. SBW had been well contained all series, but Ireland failed to contain him this match. Conrad Smith was again the unsung hero of the backline, making the right decisions every time both in attack and defense. Despite the big scoreline the outside backs didn't really get the ball in space that much, but all had good games. I was a bit worried when Gear stuffed up the first two high kicks but he recovered very well, and scored a great try. What really impressed me was the aggression he brought to he game - not only with ball in hand, but he was also smashing people in defense. Smith was solid on the right wing - his ability to seamlessly slot in anywhere in backline is a big asset, while Dagg too was solid at fullback (and made some massive punts). Hard to identify many standouts for Ireland. Healy made a couple of good runs, but did miss a few tackles (he will want to forget Romano running straight through him). I was again impressed by Ryan - he was solid all round, and good at the lineout. I remain unconvinced by Touhy though - his work-rate doesn't impress me, and he made a few basic errors. O'Brien was probably the pick of the loosies again, but he is far from the devastating ball running that we were promised at the start of the series. He got driven back numerous times in the tackle, but he did do a good job of disrupting New Zealand's ball at the breakdown on a number of occasions. Can't name any standouts in the backs, though it is hard to stand out when your forwards are completely outplayed. Overall I was delighted by the performance - bring on the Rugby Championship! [/QUOTE]
Verification
Post reply
Forums
Rugby Union
International Test Matches
Spring Tour: New Zealand vs Ireland - 3rd Test. (23/6/2012, 07:35 GMT)
Top