• Help Support The Rugby Forum :

Super14 team of the year

Which games did Giteau play at 10?

I can't really remember, and you haven't answered?

So what if he passed the ball 7 times? That doesn't mean much.. What were the other stats? ie. runs, kicks etc? I find it hard to believe he only touched the ball 7 times in 80 minutes.

Donald doesn't need to score tries, he has the backs to do it for him. Thats why Donald has a shitload of conversions (and misses :p).
 
If you are going to claim that Donald had a better season than Giteau, then surely you would have watched all of Giteaus games thus know how games he played @10 right?.... thought not.

To answer your question, Gitz played almost every game of the year at 10 - there was 3/4 games where Hilgendorf played 10 (one of those games Giteau was injured).
 
I just saw that Giteau started 8 games as #10.


To be honest, I only watched the Force games against the Blues, Chiefs, and the Crusaders. So I guess he wouldn't look as good as Donald lolz..

Donald was playing well in the 'crunch' end of the season, and it's not like they were easy games either.
 
Sorry Truth but the real Truth is that Donald had a much better season than Giteau. He scored crucial tries, set-up wonderful tries and kicked the necessary goals. He led his backline well.
 
1. Gurthrow Steenkamp
2. Gary Botha
3. Neemia Tialata
4. Bakkies Botha
5. Victor Matfield
6. Schalk Burger
7. Luke Watson
8. Pierre Spies
9. Ruan Pienaar
10. Dan Carter
11. JP Pietersen
12. Aaron Mauger
13. Isaia Toeava
14. Bryan Habana
15. Francois Steyn
 
Mauger over McAlister ruins a perfectly good team.

Even the Cantabs have to admit McAlister has blown Mauger away all season.
 
Here's mine

1 Steenkamp
2 Smit
3 Hayman
4 Flavell (Bakkies would of taken his place if he played more games)
5 Matfield
6 Juan Smith (my player of the S14)
7 George Smith/Burger
8 Hoiles (hugely underated!)
9 Fourie du Preez
10 Giteau
11 Habana
12 Mauger/McAlister. Too close to call. For all the Mauger haters out there...he ran the crusaders backline much better than DC did
13 Toeava
14 Shepard/Sivivatu/Masaga
15 Huxley
 
HERE IS MY SUPER 14 TEAM

1.Gurthrow Steenkamp
2.Schalk Brits
3.Carl Hayman
4.Bakkies Botha
5.Victor Matfield
6.Luke Watson
7.Schalk Burger
8.Pierre Spies
9.Fourie du Preez
10.Dan Carter
11.Bryan Habana
12.Matt Giteau
13.Isaia Toeava
14.Rico Gear
15.Frans Steyn

16.Gary Botha
17.BJ Botha
18.Johann Muller
19.Richard McCaw
20.Ruan Pienaar
21.Luke McAlister
22.Drew Mitchell
 
HERE IS MY SUPER 14 TEAM

1.Gurthrow Steenkamp
2.Schalk Brits
3.Carl Hayman
4.Bakkies Botha
5.Victor Matfield
6.Luke Watson
7.Schalk Burger
8.Pierre Spies
9.Fourie du Preez
10.Dan Carter
11.Bryan Habana
12.Matt Giteau
13.Isaia Toeava
14.Rico Gear
15.Frans Steyn

16.Gary Botha
17.BJ Botha
18.Johann Muller
19.Richard McCaw
20.Ruan Pienaar
21.Luke McAlister
22.Drew Mitchell [/b]



Can see you're a Stormers/WP supporter. Schalk Britz and Luke Watson come on be serious.
 
My Super Rugby XV Picked on Form

15 - Percy Montgomery
14 - Brian Habana
13 - Stirling Mortlock
12 - Matt Giteau
11 - Doug Howlett
10 - Steven Brett
9 - Rune Pienaar

8- Nic Williams
7 - Shalk Burger
6 - Rocky Elsom
5 - Victor Matfield
4 - Nathan Sharpe
3 - Os du Randt
2 - John Smit
1 - John schwalger
 
1. G.Steenkamp
2. G.Botha
3. C.Hayman
4. B.Botha
5. C.Jack
6. S.Burger/J.Smith
7. R.McCaw/B.Skinstad
8. P.Spies/R.Kankowski
9. F.Du Preez
10. D.Carter
11. B.Habana
12. M.Giteau
13. L.McAlister
14. J.Rockoko
15. J.Huxlye
 
1. d carstens

2. g botha (would of liked to see tatafu polota nau but frier on great form)

3. bj botha

4. t flavel

5. m chisolm

6. s burger

7. smith/ hoiles

8. tuiali'i/ lauaki

9. f du preez

10. m giteau

11. b habana

12. l mcalister

13. i toeava

14. Roy Kinikinilau

15. cameron shepard





maybe abit late to say, and cameron shepard should be in the wallabies cup squad
 
1 - John Schwalger/Wyatt Crockett/Os Du Randt

2 - Derren Witcombe/Corey Flynn

3 - Carl Hayman/CJ Van Der Linde

4 - Troy Flavell/Jono Gibbes

5 - Ali Williams/Greg Rawlinson

6 - Jerry Collins/George Smith

7 - :wall: Richie McCaw

8 - Rodney So'oialo

9 - Alby Mathewson

10 - Stephen Brett/Matt Giteau

11 - Bryan Habana

12 - Luke McAlister :%#%#:

13 - Tana Umaga :wah:

14 - Doug Howlett

15 - Percy Montgomery
 
1. G.Steenkamp
2. G.Botha
3. C.Haymen
4. B.Botha
5. C.Jack
6. S.Burger
7. R. McCaw
8. P.Spies

9. F.du Preez
10. S.Brett
11. B.Habana
12. L.McAlister
13. J.de Villiers
14. D.Howlett
15. F.Steyn

The best
 
I probably should have read this before starting this years fantasy super 14 game.
It's no wonder my team's rubbish
 

Latest posts

Top