• Help Support The Rugby Forum :

who is the worlds best player?

E

Energizer

Guest
Too hard to answer. Could be answered if we were talking about different positions
 
C

Camp0

Guest
so, let do it, best players based on current form.


best props :
best hooker :
best lock in the world : victor matfield.
best flankers :
best no8 :
best scrumhalf :
best flyhalf :
best centres :
best wingers :
best fullback :
 
I

Incredible Schalk

Guest
Great idea ;)

best props :Sheridan
best hooker :Smit
best lock in the world : Matfield.
best flankers : Burger
best no8 : Sharpe
best scrumhalf : Du Preez
best flyhalf :Carter, just ahead of James
best centres :Mortlock
best wingers : Habana
best fullback :Muliana
 
C

candybum

Guest
No such thing. Would be an entirely pointless debate. [/b]

Yes thats true, the different decades and the different eras had produced some fine as (rugby ability wise!) rugby players!
 
F

Fa'atau82

Guest
All the players around now are conditioned pros with conditioned pro lifestyle. You can't compare a player like Brian Moore with say, John Smit. Players these days have much more opportunity to develop than in the amateur days.

I think you;d have to have a debate on the best amateur and the best pro.
 
C

Camp0

Guest
here is my full list of players :

best props : sheridan, hayman
best hooker : smit
best lock in the world : matfield, botha
best flankers : burger, mccaw
best no8 : collins
best scrumhalf : du preez
best flyhalf : wilkonson
best centres : o'driscoll, mortlock
best wingers : habana, rockoko
best fullback : latham
 
N

nam97

Guest
Jerry Collins is the greatest player on the planet. He'd be an automatic first choice loosie for anyone. He's the real soul in the AB's, not McCaw.
 
S

Sir Speedy

Guest
best props :Sheridan
best hooker :Smit
best lock in the world : Matfield.
best flankers : Burger, Dussatoir (sp?)
best no8 : Sharpe
best scrumhalf : Du Preez, Pichot (Mike Blair, even)
best flyhalf : Juan Martin Hernandez
best centres : Luke Mcalister, Matt Giteau
best wingers : Habana, Vincent Clerc
best fullback : Jason Robinson
 
D

Dmx#1

Guest
best props :Sheridan
best hooker :Smit
best lock in the world : Matfield.
best flankers : Burger, Dussatoir (sp?)
best no8 : Sharpe
best scrumhalf : Du Preez, Pichot (Mike Blair, even)
best flyhalf : Juan Martin Hernandez
best centres : Luke Mcalister, Matt Giteau
best wingers : Habana, Vincent Clerc
best fullback : Jason Robinson
[/b]

Coco, Sivi, Howlett >>>>>>>> Clerc
 
I

Incredible Schalk

Guest
<div class='quotemain'> best props :Sheridan
best hooker :Smit
best lock in the world : Matfield.
best flankers : Burger, Dussatoir (sp?)
best no8 : Sharpe
best scrumhalf : Du Preez, Pichot (Mike Blair, even)
best flyhalf : Juan Martin Hernandez
best centres : Luke Mcalister, Matt Giteau
best wingers : Habana, Vincent Clerc
best fullback : Jason Robinson
[/b]

Coco, Sivi, Howlett >>>>>>>> Clerc
[/b][/quote]


Yes but if you play for the All Blacks rather than France you are always going to show better in the New Zealand team. They play a wider, more constructive game making it far easier for guys like Howlett to score tries. I agree i think Clerc is a great winger, probably 4th behind Habana,Rockoko and Sivivatu.
 
C

Cusker

Guest
best props : sheridan, hayman
best hooker : Smit
best lock in the world : victor matfield.
best flankers : McCaw,
best no8 :Chabal
best scrumhalf :pichot
best flyhalf :Carter
best centres :Can't decide to many for me.
best wingers :Habana,Lemi
best fullback :Latham
 
S

Sir Speedy

Guest
<div class='quotemain'> best props :Sheridan
best hooker :Smit
best lock in the world : Matfield.
best flankers : Burger, Dussatoir (sp?)
best no8 : Sharpe
best scrumhalf : Du Preez, Pichot (Mike Blair, even)
best flyhalf : Juan Martin Hernandez
best centres : Luke Mcalister, Matt Giteau
best wingers : Habana, Vincent Clerc
best fullback : Jason Robinson
[/b]

Coco, Sivi, Howlett >>>>>>>> Clerc
[/b][/quote]
/care? :huh:
 
A

Ash/blubber

Guest
best props :Sheridan
best hooker :Ibanez
best lock in the world : Matfield.
best flankers : Burger
best no8 : Sharpe or Dialligo ( but he is past his best :( )
best scrumhalf : Du Preez, Pichot
best flyhalf : Hernandez or Carter
best centres : Luke Mcalister, o' Driscall
best wingers : Habana, Rockococo
best fullback : Jason Robinson
 
D

Dmx#1

Guest
<div class='quotemain'>
<div class='quotemain'> best props :Sheridan
best hooker :Smit
best lock in the world : Matfield.
best flankers : Burger, Dussatoir (sp?)
best no8 : Sharpe
best scrumhalf : Du Preez, Pichot (Mike Blair, even)
best flyhalf : Juan Martin Hernandez
best centres : Luke Mcalister, Matt Giteau
best wingers : Habana, Vincent Clerc
best fullback : Jason Robinson
[/b]

Coco, Sivi, Howlett >>>>>>>> Clerc
[/b][/quote]
/care? :huh: [/b][/quote]

:sex011:
 

Latest posts

Top