Menu
Forums
New posts
Search forums
What's new
New posts
Latest activity
Log in
Register
What's new
Search
Search
Search titles and first posts only
Search titles only
By:
New posts
Search forums
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Help Support The Rugby Forum :
Forums
Rugby Union
International Test Matches
[2014 Mid-Year Tests] New Zealand
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Reply to thread
Message
<blockquote data-quote="Darwin" data-source="post: 632335" data-attributes="member: 24910"><p>Carter will miss the June Internationals as you say, but he is not quite out for the entire Super Rugby season. He is expected back for the Crusaders in early July, which will hopefully give him a few games of rugby before the Rugby Championship (which starts mid August).</p><p></p><p>Cane is back from injury now (he started for the Chiefs last week against the Force), and is certainly seen as the next in line for the 7 jersey behind McCaw. The interesting thing about Cane is that he has never really shone that much at Super Rugby level, but has always impressed at test level (despite the fact he is still very young). His style of play just seems to suit test rugby better than Super Rugby. He has many of the same attributes that McCaw has - he is a big physical 7, is a strong ball runner, makes huge numbers of tackles, runs excellent support lines, and never seems to slow down. His ball handling still lets him down at Super Rugby level, and he still needs to improve at the breakdown, but 'pilfering' ability is no longer the main thing the AB's selectors want from their 7.</p><p></p><p>Matt Todd is next in line after Cane, and I've been impressed with the way his game has evolved over the last couple of years. Originally he was perhaps a bit one dimensional - he was outstanding at the breakdown, but the rest of his game needed work. His breakdown work is perhaps less noticeable these days but his ball running has improved immensely, and he is certainly a more physical player than he has been in the past. Ardie Savea is one for the future and brings a completely different dimension to the 7 jersey with his freakish athleticism, but he still lacks the physicality required at Super Rugby level, let alone test level (though I have no doubt this will come once his body matures). I still believe the best 7 in Super Rugby for the last 3 years has been Luke Braid, but for some reason the AB's selectors don't seem to be a fan on him. He is a deceptively powerful ball runner, offloads as well as any loose-forward, makes plenty of tackles, and is handy at the breakdown. Perhaps the only things that counts against him is that he isn't really a lineout option, but with the likes of Messam, Luatua, and Read this shouldn't be a major issue.</p><p></p><p>Onto McCaw himself. To be honest I am a bit worried about McCaw. There is no doubt that his age (and the punishment he has taken in 12+ years of professional rugby) is taking its tool. He doesn't have the pace he once had, and because of this he is turning up to breakdowns a fraction of a second latter than previously. This fraction of a second can make all the difference. He is still capable of slowing down opposition ball as well as any in world rugby, however he seldom is able to produce the turnovers that were once his trademark, but he he still gets heavily penalized. These days he is a powerful ball ball runner, he is still a excellent defender (though again perhaps he lack of pace is starting to effect this aspect of his play too), and his leadership and experience in 2nd to none on the international stage. He tends to take some time to build into a season these days so his current thumb injury is a worry. He is still probably our best option at 7 at the current time, but he is certainly nearing the end of his career, and I'm not certain whether his still the best option at 7 in a years time (or even by the end of this year)...</p><p></p><p></p><p></p><p>I think that's a very good summary of what the AB's want from their 7, and is the main reason I don't see Ardie Savea featuring in black anytime soon (as he plays a very different style).</p><p></p><p></p><p></p><p>Lowe has impressed in his brief appearances, but I would say he is very unlikely to feature. He had a breakthrough season with Tasman during the ITM Cup, and has hasn't looked out of place at the Chiefs. He seems to have lost a lot of weight recently, and because of that seems a lot quicker. The challenge for him will be establishing himself in the Chiefs lineup first and foremost, as the Chiefs have an abundance of outside back talent. Unfortunately he is currently injured (out for 6 weeks with a knee injury), so that will make that a lot harder! The AB's have plenty of depth in the outside backs so they aren't really looking for a wing at the moment, but he has certainly made a promising start to his Chiefs career.</p></blockquote><p></p>
[QUOTE="Darwin, post: 632335, member: 24910"] Carter will miss the June Internationals as you say, but he is not quite out for the entire Super Rugby season. He is expected back for the Crusaders in early July, which will hopefully give him a few games of rugby before the Rugby Championship (which starts mid August). Cane is back from injury now (he started for the Chiefs last week against the Force), and is certainly seen as the next in line for the 7 jersey behind McCaw. The interesting thing about Cane is that he has never really shone that much at Super Rugby level, but has always impressed at test level (despite the fact he is still very young). His style of play just seems to suit test rugby better than Super Rugby. He has many of the same attributes that McCaw has - he is a big physical 7, is a strong ball runner, makes huge numbers of tackles, runs excellent support lines, and never seems to slow down. His ball handling still lets him down at Super Rugby level, and he still needs to improve at the breakdown, but 'pilfering' ability is no longer the main thing the AB's selectors want from their 7. Matt Todd is next in line after Cane, and I've been impressed with the way his game has evolved over the last couple of years. Originally he was perhaps a bit one dimensional - he was outstanding at the breakdown, but the rest of his game needed work. His breakdown work is perhaps less noticeable these days but his ball running has improved immensely, and he is certainly a more physical player than he has been in the past. Ardie Savea is one for the future and brings a completely different dimension to the 7 jersey with his freakish athleticism, but he still lacks the physicality required at Super Rugby level, let alone test level (though I have no doubt this will come once his body matures). I still believe the best 7 in Super Rugby for the last 3 years has been Luke Braid, but for some reason the AB's selectors don't seem to be a fan on him. He is a deceptively powerful ball runner, offloads as well as any loose-forward, makes plenty of tackles, and is handy at the breakdown. Perhaps the only things that counts against him is that he isn't really a lineout option, but with the likes of Messam, Luatua, and Read this shouldn't be a major issue. Onto McCaw himself. To be honest I am a bit worried about McCaw. There is no doubt that his age (and the punishment he has taken in 12+ years of professional rugby) is taking its tool. He doesn't have the pace he once had, and because of this he is turning up to breakdowns a fraction of a second latter than previously. This fraction of a second can make all the difference. He is still capable of slowing down opposition ball as well as any in world rugby, however he seldom is able to produce the turnovers that were once his trademark, but he he still gets heavily penalized. These days he is a powerful ball ball runner, he is still a excellent defender (though again perhaps he lack of pace is starting to effect this aspect of his play too), and his leadership and experience in 2nd to none on the international stage. He tends to take some time to build into a season these days so his current thumb injury is a worry. He is still probably our best option at 7 at the current time, but he is certainly nearing the end of his career, and I'm not certain whether his still the best option at 7 in a years time (or even by the end of this year)... I think that's a very good summary of what the AB's want from their 7, and is the main reason I don't see Ardie Savea featuring in black anytime soon (as he plays a very different style). Lowe has impressed in his brief appearances, but I would say he is very unlikely to feature. He had a breakthrough season with Tasman during the ITM Cup, and has hasn't looked out of place at the Chiefs. He seems to have lost a lot of weight recently, and because of that seems a lot quicker. The challenge for him will be establishing himself in the Chiefs lineup first and foremost, as the Chiefs have an abundance of outside back talent. Unfortunately he is currently injured (out for 6 weeks with a knee injury), so that will make that a lot harder! The AB's have plenty of depth in the outside backs so they aren't really looking for a wing at the moment, but he has certainly made a promising start to his Chiefs career. [/QUOTE]
Verification
Post reply
Forums
Rugby Union
International Test Matches
[2014 Mid-Year Tests] New Zealand
Top