psychic duck
International
- Joined
- Mar 7, 2011
- Messages
- 5,094
Vote in the Poll !!!
my choice Read
my choice Read
Vote in the Poll !!!
my choice Read
read is better but no Reuben Thorne?
Read shouldn't be there yet. He is a very good 8, but its too early in his career to be judging his greatness against the others listed.
I chose Scott Robertson
I hated Read back in 2008, thought he was Mr Average. My god I was wrong. In terms of comparrison, I'd have to give it to Read. Read has already played 7 more All Black tests than Robertson, 21 more tests than Moses Tuiali'i and 15 more than Cribb, and he has certainly made the most amount of impact since Brooke. He will probably need to play longer for the Crusaders, but he's in my mind better than the other three.
I hated Read back in 2008, thought he was Mr Average. My god I was wrong. In terms of comparrison, I'd have to give it to Read. Read has already played 7 more All Black tests than Robertson, 21 more tests than Moses Tuiali'i and 15 more than Cribb, and he has certainly made the most amount of impact since Brooke. He will probably need to play longer for the Crusaders, but he's in my mind better than the other three.