• Help Support The Rugby Forum :

Premiership Rugby 21/22 - Rd 4

While Sarries deserved the win, I think Newcastle will be rueing their mistakes. Too many penalties made it to easy for Sarries to build a lead. But Blamire missed a great opportunity to level near the end which could well have secured at least a BP for Newcastle.
 
I think that's a red under the current frameworks

If I were a ref I'd go yellow, too, but it feels very inconsistent to how it's been reffed before

Saints will be happy with the uncontested scrums
Inconsistent is the name of the game at the moment, let’s be honest the Sarries loss to Leicester with the blatant charge to the head on the deck which should have reversed the pen that led to the winning score should have been a red all day it was reckless and unnecessary, not to mention a number of others felt to me like A ball hit first and B the chest made the majority of the initial contact not the arm, I don’t disagree that many refs many times would give a red but I think it’s a stretch to talk about consistency at this stage….
 
Inconsistent is the name of the game at the moment, let’s be honest the Sarries loss to Leicester with the blatant charge to the head on the deck which should have reversed the pen that led to the winning score should have been a red all day it was reckless and unnecessary, not to mention a number of others felt to me like A ball hit first and B the chest made the majority of the initial contact not the arm, I don’t disagree that many refs many times would give a red but I think it’s a stretch to talk about consistency at this stage….
Yes i agree. The leicester game should have been reversed and if we take the Oghre challenge. We all agree for the most part, we would see that as a yellow as not shoulder hit, however by rules strictly its red but interpretation of two different refs found yellow/red.

Very odd.
 

Latest posts

Sponsored
UnlistMe
Back
Top