D
dobrien7
Guest
I'm a kiwi and I'm saying let them try again...
always at the defence arent you...Originally posted by sanzar+Apr 29 2006, 03:50 PM-->Originally posted by THE CHIROPRACTOR101@Apr 29 2006, 02:21 PM
<!--QuoteBegin-St Helens RLFCWell if you think about it, thats EXACTLY what sidhe did! They tried to implement as many of the fans wishes as possible! The problem was that trying to jam that much content into a low budget game that is still only starting out is going to result in poor execution... It's up to them to take things a bit more slowly for future versions and iron out the problems with RL2. [/b]@Apr 27 2006, 03:21 AM
Got ideas to improve SIDHE's next effort, should they make one?
Discuss.
ideas?....mario try listening to YOUR community who want and need this game..listen to there wants and needs and see if you can atleast measure up to it..becoz ya last game was rugby 2004 with out rucks and mauls...f*** you if you disagree...that game was crap
im happy i didnt purchase the pile of junk..
but listen to the community,obviously flash graphics is eye candy..but the GAMEPLAY entirely makes the game..all the other **** on the side contribute to make the product greater
First up I didn't put the knobhead thing under your name... Second thing is that WE didn't ask for ****! The majority of the fans wanted Franchise modes and Online play and didn't ask too much of gameplay, so in that sense Sidhe delivered!Originally posted by THE CHIROPRACTOR101+Apr 30 2006, 01:14 AM-->Originally posted by sanzar@Apr 29 2006, 03:50 PM
Originally posted by THE CHIROPRACTOR101@Apr 29 2006, 02:21 PM
<!--QuoteBegin-St Helens RLFCalways at the defence arent you...@Apr 27 2006, 03:21 AM
Got ideas to improve SIDHE's next effort, should they make one?
Discuss.
ideas?....mario try listening to YOUR community who want and need this game..listen to there wants and needs and see if you can atleast measure up to it..becoz ya last game was rugby 2004 with out rucks and mauls...f*** you if you disagree...that game was crap
im happy i didnt purchase the pile of junk..
but listen to the community,obviously flash graphics is eye candy..but the GAMEPLAY entirely makes the game..all the other **** on the side contribute to make the product greater
Well if you think about it, thats EXACTLY what sidhe did! They tried to implement as many of the fans wishes as possible! The problem was that trying to jam that much content into a low budget game that is still only starting out is going to result in poor execution... It's up to them to take things a bit more slowly for future versions and iron out the problems with RL2.
we asked for gameplay..what did we get?...NOTHING
take that tag you put under my name and put it on yours,where it rightfully belongs..
truth is (and everyone recognises this..coz if you dont yor just stupid)..the game play sucked [/b]
excuse me?.....franchise and blah blah..yes yesOriginally posted by sanzar+Apr 30 2006, 02:22 AM-->Originally posted by THE CHIROPRACTOR101@Apr 30 2006, 01:14 AM
Originally posted by sanzar@Apr 29 2006, 03:50 PM
Originally posted by THE CHIROPRACTOR101@Apr 29 2006, 02:21 PM
<!--QuoteBegin-St Helens RLFCFirst up I didn't put the knobhead thing under your name... Second thing is that WE didn't ask for ****! The majority of the fans wanted Franchise modes and Online play and didn't ask too much of gameplay, so in that sense Sidhe delivered!@Apr 27 2006, 03:21 AM
Got ideas to improve SIDHE's next effort, should they make one?
Discuss.
ideas?....mario try listening to YOUR community who want and need this game..listen to there wants and needs and see if you can atleast measure up to it..becoz ya last game was rugby 2004 with out rucks and mauls...f*** you if you disagree...that game was crap
im happy i didnt purchase the pile of junk..
but listen to the community,obviously flash graphics is eye candy..but the GAMEPLAY entirely makes the game..all the other **** on the side contribute to make the product greater
Well if you think about it, thats EXACTLY what sidhe did! They tried to implement as many of the fans wishes as possible! The problem was that trying to jam that much content into a low budget game that is still only starting out is going to result in poor execution... It's up to them to take things a bit more slowly for future versions and iron out the problems with RL2.
always at the defence arent you...
we asked for gameplay..what did we get?...NOTHING
take that tag you put under my name and put it on yours,where it rightfully belongs..
truth is (and everyone recognises this..coz if you dont yor just stupid)..the game play sucked
But seriously Chiro, go back and read my post again, it makes perfect sense (seriously, if you actually understood my post there is no way you could have come up with that response, so I assumed you skimmed it)... What you're whinging on about is begining to make me suspect you're English. [/b]
Well if you think about it, thats EXACTLY what sidhe did![/b]
Mate, deadset you're an absolute idiot. I love you and all, but seriously you just can't seem to grasp what I'm saying. I haven't been defending the gameplay at all, I've simply said that sidhe tried implement TOO MUCH of what the fans asked for... and like it or not gameplay wasn't the be all and end all for everyone, otherwise they wouldn't have put so much effort into all those masses of other things! Just think about it for 2 seconds and you'll realise that logistically this game was always in danger of ending out half baked because of how much they promised to put in it with so little money behind it and being only the second ***le in the series... But that said, I think there is great hope for the series, because if they just work on refining what they've got now it'll become a really good game!Originally posted by THE CHIROPRACTOR101@Apr 30 2006, 01:34 AM
excuse me?.....franchise and blah blah..yes yes
the core improvement wanted from fans was for better gameplay....go and read back on my posts and many many others..while mario was here talking to his community he chose fancyness over the key elements which make games sucessful...
THE GAMEPLAY
ill spell it out again..
T-H-E G-A-M-E-P-L-A-Y
Dreams are freeOriginally posted by sanzar+Apr 29 2006, 06:30 PM--><!--QuoteBegin-Kimmy_The_KiwiYour dreaming, EA will never make a rugby league game. [/b]@Apr 29 2006, 05:28 PM
Yes they should make a new one..but ea should make it...they keep on making the rugby games better and better each year just when we thought they couldnt get better![]()
Originally posted by sanzar+Apr 30 2006, 02:42 AM--><!--QuoteBegin-THE CHIROPRACTOR101Mate, deadset you're an absolute idiot. I love you and all, but seriously you just can't seem to grasp what I'm saying. I haven't been defending the gameplay at all, I've simply said that sidhe tried implement TOO MUCH of what the fans asked for... and like it or not gameplay wasn't the be all and end all for everyone, otherwise they wouldn't have put so much effort into all those masses of other things! Just think about it for 2 seconds and you'll realise that logistically this game was always in danger of ending out half baked because of how much they promised to put in it with so little money behind it and being only the second ***le in the series... But that said, I think there is great hope for the series, because if they just work on refining what they've got now it'll become a really good game! [/b]@Apr 30 2006, 01:34 AM
excuse me?.....franchise and blah blah..yes yes
the core improvement wanted from fans was for better gameplay....go and read back on my posts and many many others..while mario was here talking to his community he chose fancyness over the key elements which make games sucessful...
THE GAMEPLAY
ill spell it out again..
T-H-E G-A-M-E-P-L-A-Y
Yeah, you're right, got a bit too overzealous with that commentOriginally posted by C A Iversen+Apr 30 2006, 11:27 AM-->Originally posted by sanzar@Apr 30 2006, 02:42 AM
<!--QuoteBegin-THE CHIROPRACTOR101@Apr 30 2006, 01:34 AM
excuse me?.....franchise and blah blah..yes yes
the core improvement wanted from fans was for better gameplay....go and read back on my posts and many many others..while mario was here talking to his community he chose fancyness over the key elements which make games sucessful...
THE GAMEPLAY
ill spell it out again..
T-H-E G-A-M-E-P-L-A-Y
Mate, deadset you're an absolute idiot. I love you and all, but seriously you just can't seem to grasp what I'm saying. I haven't been defending the gameplay at all, I've simply said that sidhe tried implement TOO MUCH of what the fans asked for... and like it or not gameplay wasn't the be all and end all for everyone, otherwise they wouldn't have put so much effort into all those masses of other things! Just think about it for 2 seconds and you'll realise that logistically this game was always in danger of ending out half baked because of how much they promised to put in it with so little money behind it and being only the second ***le in the series... But that said, I think there is great hope for the series, because if they just work on refining what they've got now it'll become a really good game!
Sanzar, that is just not like you. I mean "Mate, deadset you're an absolute idiot." ??? What does saying that to Chiro prove?
I know your frustrated that your point of view is not being taken in the way it was intended, but name-calling?
You make some good points, but essentialy a game is just that, a gameplay experience. Not everyone is obsessed with gameplay, true. It is isn't always the most important thing to everyone, but seriously good gameplay is the definition of a game.
They did try and put too much in, agreed. They just left out the main ingredient. It was like going to a BBQ that had no meat. Sure some people love the salads and bread, but how many people are truly enjoying themselves? [/b]
The Fifa comparison is pretty much right on the money.Originally posted by sanzar+Apr 30 2006, 03:41 PM-->Originally posted by C A Iversen@Apr 30 2006, 11:27 AM
Originally posted by sanzar@Apr 30 2006, 02:42 AM
<!--QuoteBegin-THE CHIROPRACTOR101Yeah, you're right, got a bit too overzealous with that comment@Apr 30 2006, 01:34 AM
excuse me?.....franchise and blah blah..yes yes
the core improvement wanted from fans was for better gameplay....go and read back on my posts and many many others..while mario was here talking to his community he chose fancyness over the key elements which make games sucessful...
THE GAMEPLAY
ill spell it out again..
T-H-E G-A-M-E-P-L-A-Y
Mate, deadset you're an absolute idiot. I love you and all, but seriously you just can't seem to grasp what I'm saying. I haven't been defending the gameplay at all, I've simply said that sidhe tried implement TOO MUCH of what the fans asked for... and like it or not gameplay wasn't the be all and end all for everyone, otherwise they wouldn't have put so much effort into all those masses of other things! Just think about it for 2 seconds and you'll realise that logistically this game was always in danger of ending out half baked because of how much they promised to put in it with so little money behind it and being only the second ***le in the series... But that said, I think there is great hope for the series, because if they just work on refining what they've got now it'll become a really good game!
Sanzar, that is just not like you. I mean "Mate, deadset you're an absolute idiot." ??? What does saying that to Chiro prove?
I know your frustrated that your point of view is not being taken in the way it was intended, but name-calling?
You make some good points, but essentialy a game is just that, a gameplay experience. Not everyone is obsessed with gameplay, true. It is isn't always the most important thing to everyone, but seriously good gameplay is the definition of a game.
They did try and put too much in, agreed. They just left out the main ingredient. It was like going to a BBQ that had no meat. Sure some people love the salads and bread, but how many people are truly enjoying themselves?. Will you ever forgive me Chiro?
h34r:
But yeah, I haven't actually been disagreeing with you guys about the gameplay, because I also think the game is fundamentally flawed... I just think that given they probably ('hopefull' may be a better word) have realised that they can't go from FIFA 99 directly to FIFA 06 in one hit (which is what it looked like they were trying to do with the amount they jammed into RL2), that the next game will be more balanced and won't overstep its boundaries in the way this one did... [/b]
i wouldnt throw it passed themOriginally posted by C A Iversen@May 1 2006, 12:28 PM
Scary thought. What if RL3 was actually worse?
Ah yes, needs more input from men who consume beer n meat, just like the men that play the game, like those manly (no pun) men Ian Roberts and John Hopoate...Originally posted by ak47@May 1 2006, 01:17 PM
they have all the spices, veggies and drinks
but no meat - not for grown ups
they even have fairy bread.........but no beer n meat
True development time wouldn't be anywhere near that, just have to wait and see I suppose...Originally posted by Candyman@May 3 2006, 03:05 PM
Good call.....but hopefully the creators have been looking at rugby 06 and thought along the same line as EA have and with the technology we have these days compared to 10 years it might not take them as long to create a better league game