Best ever all black XXII

Discussion in 'International Test Matches' started by DMac, Aug 6, 2008.

  1. DMac

    DMac Guest

    1. ?
    2. ?
    3. ?
    4. ?
    5. Chris Jack
    6. Jerry Collins
    7. Richie McCaw
    8. Rodney So'oialo
    9. ?
    10. Andrew Mehrtons
    11. Jonah Lomu
    12. Dan Carter
    13. Tana Umaga
    14. Joesevata Rokocoko?
    15. Christian Cullen

    16. ?
    17. ?
    18. ?
    19. ?
    20. ?
    21. ?
    22. ?
     
  2. Forum Ad Advertisement

  3. fcukernaut

    fcukernaut Guest

    Jack, Rocokoco, Carter, So'oialo don't even come close to making the grade. Jerry Collins is very doubtful, maybe cracks the 22 if you want him as an impact player off the bench. Merhts is 50/50 many would spring for Grant Fox and eventually Carter as well, McCaw is in a very debatable category with Josh Kronfeld and Michael Jones on an equal or above talent level. Cullen is your one lock for sure garuntee to make every list, Lomu will make most as would Umaga. But do you select Umaga as a wing or center? What about Jeff Wilson then? And John Kirwan? This could certainly be a bit of an interesting thread or it could be completely dull.
     
  4. InsaneAsylum

    InsaneAsylum Guest

    Michael Jones, Sean Fitzpatrick, Zinzan Brooke, stu wilson, buck shelford, kees mews

    i think there are a lot better allblack players from the past than in the current squad.

    and you have to throw carlos spencer in there for his "flair" :p
     
  5. nam97

    nam97 Guest

    Jesus boy what are you smoking? Have you seen any Rugby games pre 2000?

    This would be my best 15 made up only of players I have seen play.

    1. Olo Brown
    2. Sean Fitzpatrick ©
    3. Carl Hayman
    4. Chris Jack
    5. Ian Jones
    6. Michael Jones (McCaw is the better 7, Jones is still a good 6)
    7. Richie McCaw
    8. Buck Shelford (VC)

    9. Graeme Bachop
    10. Dan Carter (I've been thinking about this for a while and no one in my mind touches him)
    11. Jonah Lomu
    12. Frank Bunce (Umaga the better 13, have to fit Bunce somewhere)
    13. Tana Umaga
    14. Jeff Wilson
    15. Christian Cullen
     
  6. Caledfwlch

    Caledfwlch Guest

    1) Meeuws/Brown/Woodcock
    2) Fitz
    3) Hayman
    4) Meads
    5) Jack
    6) Collins
    7) Jones
    8) Zinzan/Shelford

    9) Bachop/Marshall
    10) Spencer
    11) Lomu
    12) Bunce
    13) Umaga
    14) Wilson
    15) Cullen
     
  7. Jer1cho

    Jer1cho Guest

    1) Meeuws
    2) Fitzpatrick
    3) Hayman
    4) Chris Jack
    5) Ian Jones
    6) Josh Kronfeld
    7) Richie McCaw
    8) Zinzan Brooke

    9) Juatin Marshall
    10) Andrew Merthens
    11) Jonah Lomu
    12) Lee Stensnes
    13) Tana Umaga
    14) Jeff Wilson
    15) Christian Cullen
     
  8. candybum

    candybum Guest

    LOLz

    ..ahem*

    1 W.Whinery/K.Meeuws (try scoring machine!)
    2 S.Fitzy
    3 C.Hayman
    4 I.Jones
    5 C.Meads
    6 I.Kirkpatrick
    7 R.McCaw/M.Jones/Waka Nathan? lol
    8 Z.Brooke/B.Shelford
    9 J.Marshall/G.Bachop
    10 Mehrts/Carter/Fox
    11 LOMU!
    12 F.Bunce
    13 T.Umaga
    14 J.Wilson/J.Kirwan
    15 C.Cullen/G.Nepia

    Its very tough especially in some positions because you cant really compare players from different eras. :wall:
     
  9. jawmalawm24

    jawmalawm24 Guest

    Lol wtf 12.Lee Stensness I hope your kidding.

    1.R.loe
    2.Fitzy
    3.S.McDowell
    4.G.Whetton
    5.M.Pierce
    6.Z.Brooke
    7.M.Jones
    8.B.Shelford
    9.D.Kirk
    10.G.Fox
    11.T.Wright
    12.C.Green
    13.J.Stanley
    14.J.Kirwan
    15.J.Gallagher

    All of these fullaz because they won the 1st and our 1 and only RWC. :D
     
  10. nam97

    nam97 Guest

    Meads has a great reputation as a player and I believe everyone (the older folk, who have seen him play) when they say how great he was. Too bad he's an outspoken twat. I'm sick hearing how things were "different" in his days and players were "harder and more manly". :rolleyes:

    f*** off Collin, no one cares.

    Oh yeah and you heard what he said about Collins after he ****** on the field right? Something like "Jerry should be ashamed of himself, players back in my day had much bigger packages". Not in those words, but that's what he more or less meant.
     
  11. Jer1cho

    Jer1cho Guest

    I met him, and he was awesome. He did have moments of brilliance. :( But if you all wanna be mean, then Frank Bunce. PFT.
     
  12. Klarkash-ton

    Klarkash-ton Guest

    well it was Taylor at 12, Green at 11, Alan Whetton at 6, and Drake at 1.

    still, out of that team I'd have Fitzy, McDowell, Jones, Shelford, Kirwan, and Gallagher, though Gallagher would probably be shaded by Cullen. And he wasn't really a Kiwi.
     
  13. punkbrain

    punkbrain Guest

    Best ever NZ 15:

    1.O.Brown
    2.S.Fitzpatrick ©
    3.C.Hayman
    4.C.Jack
    5.R.Brooke
    6.J.Collins
    7.R.McCaw
    8.Z.Brooke
    9.J.Marshall
    10.A.Merhtens
    11.J.Lomu
    12.T.Umaga
    13.F.Bunce
    14.J.Rokocoko
    15.C.Cullen
     
  14. ollybarkley

    ollybarkley Guest

    1.C. Dowd
    2.S.Fitzpatrick ©
    3.C.Hayman
    4.C.Jack
    5.R.Brooke
    6.M.Jones
    7.R.McCaw
    8.Z.Brooke
    9.G.Bachop
    10.D.Carter
    11.T.Umaga
    12.W.Little
    13.F.Bunce
    14.J Wilson
    15.C.Cullen

    16 O.Brown
    17 A. Oliver
    18 I Jones
    19 T Randell
    20 J. Marshall
    21 A Mehrtens
    22 J Lomu
     
  15. nakamura

    nakamura Guest

    I cant figure out how to quote the guy who picked carlos spencer for a Fly-Half, but what a typical blues fan! No disrespect, carlos is a very creative playmaker but Carter is clearly the better overall player. I would have him at No 10.
     
  16. 1. Craig Dowd
    2. Sean fitzpatrick
    3. Kees Meauws
    4. Ian Jones
    5. Chris Jack
    6. Jerry Collins
    7. Richie McCaw
    8. Zinzan Brooke
    9. Justin Marshall
    10. Dan Carter
    11. Jonah Lomu
    12. Walter Little
    13. Tana Umaga
    14. John Kirwin
    15. Christian Cullen

    16. Tony Woodcock
    17. Anton Oliver
    18. Colin Meads
    19. Josh Kronfeld
    20. Graeme Bachop
    21. Andrew Merhtens
    22. Jeff Wilson
     
  17. punkbrain

    punkbrain Guest

    1.C.Dowd
    2.S.Fitzpatrick ©
    3.C.Hayman
    4.C.Jack
    5.I.Jones
    6.J.Collins
    7.R.McCaw
    8.Z.Brooke
    9.J.Marshall
    10.A.Merhtens
    11.J.Lomu
    12.T.Umaga
    13.F.Bunce
    14.J.Rokocoko
    15.C.Cullen

    16.A.Oliver
    17.K.Meeuws
    18.R.Brooke
    19.J.Kronfeld
    20.D.Kirk
    21.D.Carter
    22.D.Howlett
     
  18. Jer1cho

    Jer1cho Guest

    1. Jonah Lomu
    2. Jonah Lomu
    3. Jonah Lomu
    4. Jonah Lomu
    5. Jonah Lomu
    6. Jonah Lomu
    7. Jonah Lomu
    8. Jonah Lomu

    9. Jonah Lomu
    10. Jonah Lomu
    11. Jonah Lomu
    12. Jonah Lomu
    13. Jonah Lomu
    14. Jonah Lomu
    15. Christian Cullem

    :p
     
  19. rcboi

    rcboi Guest

    15. Christian Cullen
    14. John Kirwan
    13. Tana Umaga
    12. Dan Carter
    11. Jonah Lomu
    10. Andrew Mehrtens
    9. Justin Marshall
    8. Sir Brian Lochore
    7. Richie McCaw
    6. Michael Jones
    5. Colin Meads
    4. Robin Brooke
    3. Carl Hayman
    2. Sean Fitzpatrick ©
    1. Kees Meeuws
     
  20. candybum

    candybum Guest

    Aw Christian Cullen will be scoring all the tries then lol
     
Enjoyed this thread? Register to post your reply - click here!

Share This Page