Agree with this sentiment but there are levels to it.
View attachment 25358
^^ This is what “bulky” Barbeary used to look like when he was playing his best rugby.
View attachment 25359
^^ This is him when he got leaner and took his conditioning more seriously. Agree that this didn’t suit him and he lost a lot of what made him special.
View attachment 25360
^^ This is what “bulky” Barbeary now looks like. Even compared to the original bulky Barbeary he’s noticeably larger, and for lack of a better word, plumper. I agree that he needs bulk to play his game but he’s gone too far to the opposite end of the spectrum from when he really leaned down to now just being too beefy. Also just doesn’t look anywhere near as muscular as he originally did.
Obviously that’s mostly opinion based but I think the pictures give a decent idea of how much his physique has changed from when he first made an impact.