• Help Support The Rugby Forum :

SA Rugby, NZ to push for global season

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/rugby-un...-eddie-jones-deserves-to-have-his-opinions-h/

At the moment Jones and his players have to battle with an illogically structured season. Jones’s comments about some of his Grand Slam players not putting their bodies on the line for their respective clubs since the Six Nations is a warning that coasting, of any sort, will not be tolerated.

Though this has to be correct, the unevenness of the club season, which forces players to alternate their concentration between international, Premiership and European games, is not conducive to consistent performance.

Some players are better than others at compartmentalising different challenges and it would be better for everyone if they had to do this as little as possible.

Playing domestic league games, followed by or concurrent with European games, before the Six Nations and the summer tour would make much more sense. This would allow the players, clubs and supporters to maintain a focus on one thing at a time; it would also build the momentum of each competition to a natural crescendo.

All this depends on taking the bold step of moving the Six Nations back to the end of the season and, without voices of the stature of Jones, this will not even be considered. The current conservatism and, frankly, pomposity of the Six Nations committee suggests that they do not feel they have any wider duty to the domestic game. Hitherto their only response to calls for any change to the format of the tournament has been: ‘Why change the world’s most successful rugby product?’

The answer to this is that it will not affect its popularity, might make it a better product because of preferable playing conditions and help domestic rugby generally. All too sensible, of course, but direct comment by the likes of Jones might at least ensure serious consideration was given to this important issue.

Back on topic. Interesting suggestion by Brian Moore on how to structure the European season better.
 
rugby shrould have a unified season set up world wide by alinening itself to the 12 months of the year cycle in three stages a total overhaul of the whole rugby season world wide instead of the winter seasons of the year why not the 12 months of the year
the first stage begining with the grassroots armetur club school and high school and varsity rugby level could be played from january to april within that amount of time and note that compertitons dont have to change and can still keep there current formats at that level the second stage is what is known as the pro season from may to august during the first part of that season starting in may to june compertitions like the pro dimestic comps like new zealands provincal itm cup and australia provincal comp south africas currie cup england avia premieship frances top 14 japans pro compertition and usa pro rugby comp and many others can be played at the same time and the second part from july to august can be like the super rugby championship and europe club comp and others can be played aswell and the third and final stage being the international test season played from september to december the first part of that season september to october where the championship rugby between argetina south africa australia new zealand can be played and the six nations the america comp the pacfic cup and others can be played at the same time
the second part of that season from november to december leaving room for the world cup played every four years can fit in there aswell and the british and irish lions tours can be played
THE ALL BLACKS and THE WALLABIES THE SPRINGBOKS and THE LOS PUMAS can tour the northern hemisphere in EUROPE ENGLAND WALES SCOTLAND IRELAND FRANCE and ITALY came tour downunder aswell and international friendlys and tours from around the world can allso fit in there too there are windows of oppertunity three windows of oppertunity for a unified rugby season globally which can benefit both the northern and southern hemispheres rugby
and note that no competitsions dont have to change still keep there current formats and structors inplace only differents just played at a different time of the year the other problem with this set up is there will be different climmets in different hemishperes some sunny and some winnter one of the benifits of this set up the player availability in three of these stages like top line players can be available for there club sides and pro sides and test sides and with topline players been available will also boost and strengthen the competitions of the club sides and pro sides compertitions and testside and international rugby altegether in a unified way no one loeses out and everyone is a winner there just has to be a change in mindset when rugby is played at the surtin times of the year for this to work
 
I cant see it working i mean for England i would like to see though
July - Club Preseason
August - November 1st half of season
September - AI's
December - Rest
January - March - 2nd Half of season
April - Finals of AP + euro, and 7 Nations preseason games.
May 1 weekend - June second to last weekend: 7 Nations (with Georgia being brought in and a rest weekend between Weeks 3 - 4) and Saxons games.
Last weekend of June - Rest
July - Summer Tours/U20's JRWC.

No LV cup just A league games that are played along side the AP.

Would mean most player will be getting at least 4 months rest + Preseason
Players who reach finals will be getting 3 months rest at least + preseason
Internationals will be getting 6 weeks rest No pre-season.

I guess pro 12 could follow that as well.

SH maybe could do.
July Preseason
August - October ITM cup (including finals and weeks rest)
Spetember - AI's
November - Super Rugby preseason
December - April Super Rugby (which has rest weekend etc in it + Finals in it)
May - June - Rugby Championships similar to 7 Nations with a week rest in the middle and a weeks rest at the end. (Maybe could have an A rugby championships aswell?)
July - Summer Tours - U20's JRWC.

SH players tend to get more rest than NH players anyway due to the nature of Currie cup and ITM rugby being more mixed of hopefuls and senior players.

The Top 14 though is a mess.
 
Last edited:
Why does that need a global season though?

Reduced? yes
Better co-ordinated? yeah, that'd be nice
Global? no reason whatsoever

You just mentioned the reasons why. Better coordination between NH & SH, better player welfare and also World Rugby has mentioned they want tours to return.
 
Global season is not the only, or even the best way to co-ordinate seasons; and makes no difference to player welfare whatsoever (actually, that's not true - it's worse for player welfare, as someone somewhere is playing on concrete hard pitches).
 
It all sounds good on paper, but climate varies too much from one region to the next. Having the whole world on one schedule where in some regions the youth levels play in the dead of winter with unplayable weather, and those regions will die out.
 
I cant see it working i mean for England i would like to see though
July - Club Preseason
August - November 1st half of season
September - AI's
December - Rest
January - March - 2nd Half of season
April - Finals of AP + euro, and 7 Nations preseason games.
May 1 weekend - June second to last weekend: 7 Nations (with Georgia being brought in and a rest weekend between Weeks 3 - 4) and Saxons games.
Last weekend of June - Rest
July - Summer Tours/U20's JRWC.

No LV cup just A league games that are played along side the AP.

Would mean most player will be getting at least 4 months rest + Preseason
Players who reach finals will be getting 3 months rest at least + preseason
Internationals will be getting 6 weeks rest No pre-season.

I guess pro 12 could follow that as well.

SH maybe could do.
July Preseason
August - October ITM cup (including finals and weeks rest)
Spetember - AI's
November - Super Rugby preseason
December - April Super Rugby (which has rest weekend etc in it + Finals in it)
May - June - Rugby Championships similar to 7 Nations with a week rest in the middle and a weeks rest at the end. (Maybe could have an A rugby championships aswell?)
July - Summer Tours - U20's JRWC.

SH players tend to get more rest than NH players anyway due to the nature of Currie cup and ITM rugby being more mixed of hopefuls and senior players.

The Top 14 though is a mess.

This is all good points.

But when we say global season we should steer away of the current months in which certain matches are being played. As there is no way that certain months will be used to play rugby.

For example. South Africa - November to January is our warmest time of the year where temperatures can exceed 40 degrees celsius. For player welfare it is nearly impossible conditions to play rugby in, and add to that the torrential rains some areas have and the drought other areas will have. Bloemfontein for example will have a pitch that will be as hard as concrete. Pretoria and Johannesburg will have Thunderstorms with lighting that will look like a fireworks show.

If there is going to be a global season, certain months in the year, will have to be taken out of the equation for the sake of player welfare.
 

Latest posts

Sponsored
UnlistMe
Back
Top