You only need a small number of votes to call an EGM, to pass a motion requires a significant number of votes so it’s not a certainty of a change in management. I think the clubs know a reduction in professional teams needs to happen, whoever is in place at the WRU will be the bad guy in that instance.
At the time of returning the drags back to private ownership, the WRU believed there was funding for 4 with the mainly private ownership model and them essentially then ‘buying’ player services through the contracts in place.
Changes in costs throughout rugby (there’s lots of clubs struggling) poor investment decisions and the final nail in the coffin was the WRUs decision to help endorse poor private ownership at Cardiff (which ended up putting them into administration) has led them to reevaluate.
What you are saying also assumes that the WRU have the finance or the human resources to ‘buy’ and ‘own’ the teams, they don’t and still need the private investment. Central contracts is then problematic, as you wouldn’t expect private owners of businesses to operate in a model where your main human assets are employed by an external and unpredictable body, who are mainly interested in team wales and not as much the success at club level.
Ireland and Wales are vastly different in terms of the rugby population, including player pathways, club models, population spread, infrastructure etc. Copying Ireland simply won’t work, and I don’t think that model is perfect either, although I’d love a Leinster in Cardiff. Celtic cousins or not, it’s very different here and we need a solution that suits Wales, not another country.
Which leads us back to localisation...
Noone wanted the regions, it was sold to us as an Irish successful model, and then noone wanted the regions we got.
The regions have failed, the WRU have made mistep after mistep, even with anouncing the loss of a region before deciding, Welsh international players agents are all in England and France touting their talent currently, weve just lost captain and vice to Glos, Wainright to Leicester, LRZ wanted a Cardiff return but couldnt take the risk, and now rumours circling around Tom Bowen, Morgan Morse, and Alex Mann. Young players whos profiles are building wanting out.
Cut a region and itll be the final nail in the coffin of Welsh rugby, who will become 2nd tier (not just in int performances).
The section i sit in of season ticket holders constantly talk about quitting the season tickets, because its not value for money, and not an enjoyable experience, and thats when its cold, dark wet and Cardiff are winning lol.
If a region goes, thats me done with my ticket, ill stop buying the 8 i do now, all thebgames are late friday and saturday nights, the kids struggle, its much easier to sit in a pub and watch it on generic sports channel 7 or whoever buys it next season!
Ultimately the WRU want full control, but cannot afford full control, they will endorse and then battle anyone who spends their money, who in their right mind would see a welsh rugby club as a viable investment?!?!?!
I genuinely think what we need, is to control our own game, drop to a 12 team prem, private owners (locals probably) 3 prem teams per region, then compete on the european stage as 4 regions.
Club playing rosters wont be much worse than we will have next season, but itll allow extra exposure to younger players, kick offs can be at appropriate times, allowing for better fan engagement, hell there will even be away fans in the stadium lol.
Finances will be lean, but it will be ours, and i genuinely think the loss of URC money will be recouped by extra feet through the door and a lesser tv deal (IMO) the 100 or so million from all other revrnues would still be there.
The WRU could even own a region (3 prem teams) as a development area. That they could afford.
I know i kmow im deluded, but im also sick of this ****, and dont enjoy the game much any more!