Your World X/V?

Discussion in 'General Rugby Union' started by SecondRow04, Dec 2, 2006.

  1. SecondRow04

    SecondRow04 Guest

    in edition to my ' Your England Team' i thought i would do another one. if you could pick anyone in the world form any year and put into a starting 15 who would you pick??
    Mine would be:
    1. O. Du Rant (SA)
    2. B. Moore (Eng)
    3. P. Vickery (Eng)
    4. M. Johnson (Eng)
    5. W. John-McBride (Ire)
    6. J. White (Sco)
    7. R. McCaw (NZ)
    8. D. Richards (Eng)
    9. G. Edwards (Wal)
    10. J. Wilkinson (Eng)
    11. J. Lomu (NZ)
    12. T. Horan (Aus)
    13. P. Sella (Fra)
    14. P. Rossouw (SA)
    15. J. Robinson (Eng)

    Cheers
     
  2. Forum Ad Advertisement

  3. Bullitt

    Bullitt Guest

    15 random Kiwis from 2006. That'll do.
     
  4. An Tarbh

    An Tarbh Guest

    15. Serge Blanco
    14. Gerald Davies
    13. Brian O'Driscoll
    12. Mike Gibson
    11. David Campese
    10. Dan Carter
    9. Gareth Edwards
    1. Fran Cotton
    2. Sean Fitzpatrick
    3. Carl Hayman
    4. Willie John McBride
    5. Colin Meads
    6. Fergus Slattery
    7. Richie McCaw
    8. Buck Shelford

    This is a tough one so I thought I'd pick a bench as well

    16. Brian Moore, 17. Os du Randt, 18. Martin Johnson, 19. Jean Pierre Rives, 20. Joost Van der Westhuizen, 21. Barry John, 22. JPR Williams
     
  5. Rugby_Cymru

    Rugby_Cymru Guest

    Oh, that half back pairing would be AWESOME!
    :D
     
  6. Cymro

    Cymro Guest

    1. G.Price (Wal)
    2. S.Fizpatrick (NZ)
    3. F.Cotton (Eng)
    4. J.Eales (Aus)
    5. W. John-McBride (Ire)
    6. Z.Brooke (NZ)
    7. R. McCaw (NZ)
    8. M.Davies (Wal)
    9. G. Edwards (Wal)
    10. N.Jenkins (Wal)
    11. J. Lomu (NZ)
    12. M.Gibson (Ire)
    13. D.Gerber (SA)
    14. D.Campese (Aus)
    15. J.P.R Williams (Wal)

    Some greats up there!

    Possibly I have to many Welshmen there! Possibly Dan Carter could be included at 10!
     
  7. An Tarbh

    An Tarbh Guest

    especially when Jenkins isn't even the best Welsh outhalf, probably barely in the top 5
     
  8. 9. Gareth Edwards
    10. Barry John

    11. David Duckham
    12. Mike Gibson
    13. Phillipe Sella
    14. Jonah Lomu
    15. JPR Williams


    Can't be bothered to work out the forwards, but I know I'd have Fergus Slattery at 7.
     
  9. Ripper

    Ripper Guest

    1. Craig Dowd
    2. Sean Fitzpatrick ©
    3. Olo Brown
    4. Ian Jones
    5. Colin Meads (VC)
    6. Ian Kirkpatrick
    7. Michael Jones
    8. Zinzan Brooke

    9. Gareth Edwards
    10. Grant Fox
    11. Jonah Lomu
    12. Joe Stanley
    13. Frank Bunce
    14. Jeff Wilson
    15. Christan Cullen

    ...
    20. Justin Marshall
    21. Tana Umaga
    22. George Nepia

    Awesome.

    Luke McAlister in the outer squad.
     
  10. BokMagic

    BokMagic Guest

    Hmm, I`d rather go amateur era team/ pro era team, as the game has changed so much over the past 100-odd years.

    Amateur/Professional
    15- JPR Williams/ Christian Cullen
    14-Ray Mordt/Jeff Wilson
    13-Danie Gerber/Tana Umanga
    12- Andre Boniface/Tim Horan- so no place for Mike Gibson and Phillipe Sella then- damn difficult call this!
    11- JJ Williams/ David Campese
    10- Hugo Porta/Dan Carter- no Mark Ella, Phil Bennett, Barry John- freaking impossible to pick really
    9- Gareth Edwards/Joost vd Westhuizen
    8- Hennie Muller/ Zinzan Brooke- couldn`t find a spot for Buck Shelford
    7- Michael Jones/Ritcie McCaw- and no place for J-P Rives, Michael Pratt etc.
    6- Kel Tremain/Abdel Benazzi
    5- Frik du Preez/John Eales
    4- Colin Meads/Martin Johnson- so no W-J McBride,Gordon Brown- this is really impossible to call
    3-Ken Gray/Patrico Noriega- Charlie Faulkner came pretty close- would`ve been the Pontypridd front row
    2- Bobby Windsor/Sean Fitzpatrick
    1- Graham Price/Os Du Randt- no place for Fran Cotton or Syd Millar
     
  11. An Tarbh

    An Tarbh Guest

    Alright then that's certainly an interesting approach, might give it a try meself.

    15. Blanco/Latham
    14. Campese/Wilson
    13. Sella/O'Driscoll
    12. Gibson/Umaga
    11. Davies/Rokocoko
    10. John/Carter
    9. Edwards/Van der Westhuizen
    1. Cotton/du Randt
    2. Fitzpatrick/Wood
    3. Millar/Hayman
    4. McBride/Johnson
    5. Meads/ Eales
    6. Prat/Hill
    7. Slattery/McCaw
    8. Shelford/Quinell
     
Enjoyed this thread? Register to post your reply - click here!

Share This Page