• Help Support The Rugby Forum :

IRB Player of the Year nominees revealed

The Rugby Forum - Global Rugby Union News, Six Nations & RWC Discussion

Help Support The Rugby Forum:

Big Ewis

Hall of Fame
Joined
Oct 10, 2011
Messages
10,573
Reaction score
4
City & State/Province
Draguignan, Var
The IRB has announced the shortlist for the 2014 Player of the Year, with two South Africans, two All Blacks and one Irishman nominated.

The 2014 nominees are: Willie le Roux (South Africa), Brodie Retallick (New Zealand), Julian Savea (New Zealand), Jonathan Sexton (Ireland) and Duane Vermeulen (South Africa).

WILLIE LE ROUX (South Africa): A strong and elusive runner from full-back, Willie le Roux has started all 10 of South Africa's Tests in 2014 to take his tally to 22 Tests since his debut against Italy in June 2013. The 25-year-old, who has scored seven Test tries, is strong under the high ball and is potentially the most exciting South Africa outside back to come onto the scene since Bryan Habana.

BRODIE RETALLICK (New Zealand): A towering presence in the lineout, Brodie Retallick's partnership with Sam Whitelock makes arguably the best second row in world rugby at present. The 23-year-old's powerful runs and work-rate across the pitch have brought him to the fore in 2014. An IRB Junior World Championship winner in 2011, Retallick has 35 Tests and one try - against South Africa in the 2013 Rugby Championship - to his name.

JULIAN SAVEA (New Zealand): With a try-scoring rate that few can match, Julian Savea has inevitably drawn comparisons with legendary All Black wing Jonah Lomu this year. The 24-year-old has scored 10 tries in 2014, including a hat-trick against England in the third Test in June, to take his tally to 29 tries in just 31 Tests. Savea was named the IRB Junior Player of the Year in 2010 after helping New Zealand win a third successive IRB Junior World Championship title.

JONATHAN SEXTON (Ireland): The oldest of the nominees at 29, Jonathan Sexton has been the stand-out player for Ireland in 2014 as they claimed the Six Nations title, a first series win in Argentina in June and the scalp of South Africa in Dublin last weekend. His control of the game at fly-half and perfect record from the kicking tee earned the 49-Test veteran the man of the match award against the Springboks.

DUANE VERMEULEN (South Africa): A classic South African number 8, Duane Vermeulen has won plaudits across the world in 2014 for his work at the breakdown, power in the tackle and his destructive ball carrying. With 26 Tests to his name, the 28-year-old was named man of the man in South Africa's 27-25 victory over world champions New Zealand in October with his battle with Kieran Read worth the admission price alone.

"The IRB World Rugby Player of the Year is one of the most prestigious accolades in Rugby and previous winners have all made a significant contribution to the international Game over the past decade, inspiring new generations of players and fans," said IRB Chairman Bernard Lapasset.

"All of these nominees have enjoyed stellar years and the focus on who will claim this accolade will add an extra dimension to the remaining November Tests."

The IRB World Rugby Player of the Year 2014 nominees were selected by the independent IRB Awards panel, chaired by Australia's Rugby World Cup 1999 winning captain John Eales.

The panel, comprising Will Greenwood, Gavin Hastings, Raphaël Ibanez, Francois Pienaar, Agustín Pichot, Scott Quinnell, Tana Umaga and Paul Wallace, has deliberated on every major Test played in 2014, starting with the RBS Six Nations and culminating with the November internationals.

"As always the panellists' independent deliberations have produced a worthy list of contenders among a strong field. It has been a year where we have seen a levelling in competition with an unpredictability in so many games now. With a spread of a couple of outside backs, a fly-half, a back-rower and a lock in contention it is not going to be an easy selection to determine the Player of the Year," said Eales.

In support of the initial nomination process, fans now have the chance to have their say on the shortlist via social media. The results of the public vote will be considered by the panel when finalising the winner.

Previous winners include Kieran Read, Dan Carter, Thierry Dusautoir, Shane Williams, Bryan Habana, Schalk Burger, Jonny Wilkinson and Richie McCaw with the two All Black centurions the only players to have won the award on more than one occasion.

The IRB World Rugby Player of the Year is one of 12 categories of awards, including the IRB World Rugby Coach of the Year, IRB World Rugby Team of the Year, IRB Women's Player of the Year, IRB Sevens Player of the Year in association with HSBC, IRB Women's Sevens Player of the Year and IRB Junior Player of the Year.








from Planet Rugby
http://www.planetrugby.com/story/0,25883,16024_9561465,00.html
 
I'm surprised to see Sexton there. Mike Brown was given the 6 nations player of the year award so I thought he might have been there. Either way I hope DUANE 'THOR' VERMEULEN gets it
 
No surprise to see Sexton there at all. Ireland have had a fantastic year and he has consistently been a part of it.

Duane or Brodie for me.
 
I'm surprised to see Sexton there. Mike Brown was given the 6 nations player of the year award so I thought he might have been there. Either way I hope DUANE 'THOR' VERMEULEN gets it

I was just thinking the other day that Sexton should win it so I was pleasantly surprised by this. He's become so important to Ireland that if he doesn't play we're half the team without him.
 
For me:

141112041805954368.jpg


The best lock right now in the world

:p
 
Yea somebody brought Sexton up on the other thread thought it wasn't a bad shout. Still I reckon it will be Dane or Brodie, which way it goes hard to say both have been really impressive. Has a lock ever won it before? As a lock I'd really like to see Brodie win it as standing out at lock for the reasons he does is worthy of a lot of praise.
 
A solid 5, my biggest question would be over Willie Le Roux because despite his class there isn't a snowball's chance in hell that he was the best fullback in the world over the last 12 months. Anyway, one of the forwards will get it, Brodie for me.
 
Delighted for Sexton, no surprise he's there especially with the criteria used he's consistently in the top 3 player on the pitch. I also look forward to hearing him speak on Friday night (pending selection against Georgia) :D.

Although he's close it's Vermeulen or Retallick for me.
 
Delighted for Sexton, no surprise he's there especially with the criteria used he's consistently in the top 3 player on the pitch. I also look forward to hearing him speak on Friday night (pending selection against Georgia) :D.

Although he's close it's Vermeulen or Retallick for me.

Why? He's an awfully boring man! :p
 
Unless they can't engage a crowd, which he can't... Anyway it was just a joke. I'm sure the Jennings/Sexton axis will be fantastically entertaining and it's unfortunate that I can't make it!

Deadpan humour doesn't really translate to the written word :(

Anyway on topic, does anyone not deserve to be there? I'm thinking maybe Savea he had a very good year but was it a great year? Saying that can't really think of anyone for certain I'd have ahead of him there.
 
No surprise to see Sexton there at all. Ireland have had a fantastic year and he has consistently been a part of it.

Duane or Brodie for me.
But I don't see how Sexton could get it if in the 6 nations he wasn't even the best player ? So how can he be nominated for the IRB player of the year when he was out shone by others in his domestic comp ?
 
But I don't see how Sexton could get it if in the 6 nations he wasn't even the best player ? So how can he be nominated for the IRB player of the year when he was out shone by others in his domestic comp ?

Because we're talking about the whole year, including june and the SA test. Also its not like Sexton wasn't there or about in the 6N was for me probably only a little behind Brown.
 
But I don't see how Sexton could get it if in the 6 nations he wasn't even the best player ? So how can he be nominated for the IRB player of the year when he was out shone by others in his domestic comp ?

Because he's been in top three players in every international match he's played unlike Brown who despite an excellen 6N had a poor summer etc.
 
But I don't see how Sexton could get it if in the 6 nations he wasn't even the best player ? So how can he be nominated for the IRB player of the year when he was out shone by others in his domestic comp ?

If that was the case, how on earth can there be 4 guys from the Rugby Championship involved? Either you don't have to be the best player, or the IRB player of the year shortlist comes down to two people every year with no regard for tests outside those competitions.
 
If that was the case, how on earth can there be 4 guys from the Rugby Championship involved? Either you don't have to be the best player, or the IRB player of the year shortlist comes down to two people every year with no regard for tests outside those competitions.
Well I think Le Roux's inclusion is a bit weird, but if you only have 1 NH guy then surely the big NH comp has to have a massive bearing on it ? I thought Brown was the best player, by a long way. Then he was poor on the hardest tour possible. Sexton was very good in the 6 nations, Brown was brilliant IMO, and then has been **** for his club. Yes he is good for his country but does club form go into this ? If so then I think Steffon Armitage could have been included.
 
Internationals only. If he hadn't blotted his copybook on the NZ tour, I reckon he'd have been there ahead of Le Roux.
 
for me:
- Sexton !!!! (sorry, needed to start this like an attention-grabbing ad): is there to represent Ireland's excellent form and consistency. It's obvious, all sports do this (rewarding one individual symbol for a larger contingent's success). Totally predictable and justified. Truth is this though: certainly, there's better out there as far as one individual and his own, only impact over a team.
- Willie....Le Roux: I usually like random as shiit stuff, like: Ran. Dom. As. Shhhhhyyyetttt. Stuff ?.. but this right here isn't even funny.
- Savea: nobody can deny his impact on a team. He's a monster and adds an entire dimension to even the by-far-best team in the world. Always going to get at least the nom., plus he's huge and likes to eat um nom nom...(please just shoot me in the ear already - PLEASE).
- Timothy Dalton oh wait that's not really funny, I mean Willie Le Roux is actually on this list for real, like, this isn't even surrealistic..

And now the actual two guys voted on here because they really do deserve the trophy rather than "just" being very very good players (or random as shhhhhhyyettt):
- Thor. Because brutal.
- Retallica. Because versatility, skill, awesome.

Aaaaaaand...I'd give it to...I just dunno. Thor has been great all year long and as awesome as Retallica is he plays for NZ, they're so good as an ensemble they wouldn't have suffer tribulations and torments without em...but then again he's much more skillful and I don't ever want to reward strength over skill...
I - just - don't - know, fellas.
 
Vermeulen for me. Also thought Le Roux lucky to get in but if yo look at the time frame and the mechanics of how they select then it makes sense. You have to stand out in a test match. Le Roux often stands out for the wrong reasons but when he gets going he gets going and he was huge in more games than not.
 
I'm not surprised at all by Sexton's inclusion. It was going to be either him or Mike Brown as representative of the Northern Hemisphere in my opinion. Given that Ireland won 6N, Sexton has averaged 13.25 points per match in International tests this year, and he plays a high impact position on the pitch he seems pretty deserving of a nomination to me.

The LeRoux selection is puzzling to me, and I'm a Bok fan. Willie was a real treat last year and gave us an added dimension running the ball, but this year his form has been inconsistent, he has handling errors and defensive lapses all too often for us. If it were up to me to choose the 5th nominee it would have been either Michael Hooper, Aaron Smith, Richie McCaw or Conrad Smith.
 
Last edited:
yep Hooper should've been there in stead of Le Roux. I mean it's not like there's a debate even between these two, quite strange...really quite strange. How in the world do you justify that choice:

- Hooper has captained a strong Wallaby side that although somewhat inconsistent has confirmed their place as 3rd best. His work rate is off the charts, he tackles, he breaks, he turns over, he contests, runs like a back, is a huge component to the Wallaby pack and an asset to Australia on the whole, maybe the best openside flanker in the world and boy there are loads who could bear that title right now...what do you have to say about the Le Roux choice ??
- ....uuuuuuhmm !...he's got a really, really nice facial hair+haircut setup ??

I mean, fkn...go figure what goes on up there at the top....
 
I actually think Kuridrani was the most deserving Australian player. He changed the way their whole backline operates when he came into the side. Creevy or another Argentinian tight forward is unlucky to miss out. The problem with the point scoring system is that it would be hard for a prop to stand out. Even in games when your scrum is dominant, props don't tend to win too many MotM awards.
 
Regardless of the nominations we all know McCaw will win ;)

For me it would be between Retallick and Vermeulen..... not sure which way I would go to be honest.

No surprise to see Savea there, as he's been scoring tries for fun at test level over the last year (and playing very well overall too). Le Roux had a few standouts games midyear so would have racked up a few points there, but I don't think anyone (apart from perhaps his mother?) would believe he's been in the top 5 players in the world this year. Hooper and Kuridrani were perhaps unlucky to miss out from the Wallabies, and I thought Aaron Smith may have got a look-in.
 
yep Hooper should've been there in stead of Le Roux. I mean it's not like there's a debate even between these two, quite strange...really quite strange. How in the world do you justify that choice:

- Hooper has captained a strong Wallaby side that although somewhat inconsistent has confirmed their place as 3rd best. His work rate is off the charts, he tackles, he breaks, he turns over, he contests, runs like a back, is a huge component to the Wallaby pack and an asset to Australia on the whole, maybe the best openside flanker in the world and boy there are loads who could bear that title right now...what do you have to say about the Le Roux choice ??
- ....uuuuuuhmm !...he's got a really, really nice facial hair+haircut setup ??

I mean, fkn...go figure what goes on up there at the top....

Yeah, Hooper deserves to be nominated. He's better than le Roux and Sexton together.

Also Jerome Kaino is better than either (le Roux and Sexton)
 
No surprise to see Sexton there at all. Ireland have had a fantastic year and he has consistently been a part of it.

Duane or Brodie for me.


And me. They both operate as though they are powered with mini-nuclear reactors, a seemingly never ending supply of power
 

Latest posts

Back
Top