Best XV ?

S

sanzar

Guest
Posted on Feb 25 2005, 09:42 PM
all star team- dont ague, nth hemfere plaeyers cant cut it

I think my side would give you a good beetin
1 R.Paperembourde France
2 K.Wood Ireland
3 G.Price Wales
4 M.Johnson England
5 O.Roumat France
6 M.Teague England
7 F.Slattery Ireland
8 M.Davies Wales


9 G.Edwards Wales
10 J.Davies Wales
11 D.Duckham England
12 M.Gibson Ireland
13 P.Sella France
14 G.Davies Wales
15 S.Blanco France
ummm... No?
 
1

187

Guest
i wud juz make a tri nations team to play the british lions!

1. Matt Dunning
2. Anton Oliver
3. Carl Hayman
4. Victor Matfield
5. Chris Jack
6. Shalk Burger
7. Richie McCaw
8. Jerry Collins

9. George Gregan
10. Stephen Larkham
11. Lote Tuqiri
12. Tana Umaga
13. Stirling Mortlock
14. Joe Rokocoko
15. Matt Rogers

16. Os du Randt
17. John Smit
18. Justin Harrison
19. George Smith
20. Justin Marshall
21. Daniel Carter
22. Mils Muliaina
 
A

ALLBLACKS

Guest
Current world 15

15.
14.Doug Howlett
13.Brian O'driscoll
12.Tana Umaga
11.joe Rokocoko
10.
9.George Gregan
8.Shalk Burger
7.Richard McCaw
6.George Smith
5.Victor Matfield
4.Chris Jack
3.Carl Hayman
2.Kevin Mealamu
1.Os Du Rant

My Fav All Time World 15 in theyre prime

15.Christian Cullen
14.Jeff Wilson
13.Joe Stanley
12.Tim Horan
11.Jonah Lomu
10.Andrew Mehrtens
9.George Gregan
8.Zinzan Brooke
7.Josh Kronfeld
6.Willie O/Micheal Jones
5.John Eales
4.Chris Jack
3.Olo Brown
2.Sean Fitzpatrick
1.Craid Dowd

Sorry no offence to northern hemisphere teams or guys like colin meads but im judging on who ive watched growing up.

Since i grew up in Tonga and New Zealand I was watching southern hemisphere games the majority of the time.

I didnt grow up watching guys like colin meads so i cant honestly pick legends like him.
 
A

ALLBLACKS

Guest
forgot lol for my current world 15

15.Mils Muliaina
10.Dan carter but guys like mehrts wilko n los i close bhind they just havnt played much recetly so i picked carter
 
J

jgough

Guest
Originally posted by sanzar+Feb 25 2005, 11:16 PM--><div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (sanzar @ Feb 25 2005, 11:16 PM)</div>
<!--QuoteBegin-jgough
@Feb 25 2005, 06:01 PM
Ooooohhh an all time rugby xv. I'll give that a go.

Here is my RUGBY XV (+ Reserves) OF ALL TIME (And players at their prime, e.g. Jonah Lomu would be Jonah from 1995)

1. Richard Loe (New Zealand)
2. Keith Wood (Ireland)
3. Jason Leonard (England)
4. Colin Meads (New Zealand)
5. John Eales (Australia)
6. Michael Jones (New Zealand)
7. Richie McCaw (New Zealand)
8. Zinzan Brook (New Zealand)
9. Gareth Edwards (Wales)
10. Johnny Wilkinson (England)
11. Jonah Lomu (New Zealand)
12. Tim Horan (Australia)
13. Brian O'Driscoll (Ireland)
14. David Campese (Australia)
15. Phillep Sellar (France)

16. Sean Fitzpatrick (New Zealand)
17. Os Du Randt (South Africa)
18. Martin Johnson (England)
19. Wayne Shelford (New Zealand)
20. Sid Going (New Zealand)
21. Neil Jenkins (Wales)
22. Jeff Wilson (New Zealand)



Jamie Gough
Thats a pretty solid side you got there Jamie! [/b]
Thank you sanzar




Jamie Gough
 
W

Wally

Guest
Originally posted by sanzar@Feb 25 2005, 01:24 PM
15.Matt Rogers (Aus) - on last years early S12 form
14.Rupeni Caucaunibuca (Fiji)
13.Mat Giteau (Aus)
12.Brian O'Driscoll (Ire)
11.Lote Tuquri (Aus) - best winger in the world with Caucau IMO
10.Steve Larkham (Aus)/Brad Fittler
(I plan on creating him in the game)
9.Frederic Michalak (Fra)
8.Rodney So'oialo (NZ)
7.George Smith (Aus)
6.Shalk Burger (SA)
5.Chris Jack (NZ)
4.Fabien pelous (Fra)
3.Pieter De villers (Fra)
2.Keven Mealamu (NZ)
1.Os Du Randt (SA)

Reserves:
16.Phil Vickery (Eng)
17.Brendan Cannon (Aus)
18.Victor Matfeild (SA)
19.Richie McCaw (NZ)
20.George Gregan (Aus)
21.Joe Rococoko (NZ)
22.Gavin Hansen (Wales)
I think that form is well and truly out of date.
 
L

Los Lover

Guest
Mmmmmm....

OK - current...mixture of form and bias!

1. Vetiyaki (spell check)...cos looking at him makes you laugh with fear!
or, more realisticly, Du Randt
2. Kevin Mealamu
3. Carl Hayman
4. Victor Matfield
5. Chris Jack
6. George Smith
7. Richard McCaw
8. Jerry Collins

9. George Gregan

10. Daniel Carter (kicker)

11. Joe Rokocoko
12. Matt Giteau
13. Stirling Mortlock
14. Sitiveni Sivivatu
15. Matt Rogers

reserves: Saimone Taumopeau, Jeremy Paul, Sione Lauaki, Phil Waugh, Carlos Spencer, Tana Umaga, Rupeni Caucaunibuca (all either solid or capable of making an impact)

Oh oh! Where are all my NH players?



nah just jokes.....even though admittedly I have none. I came close to adding Robinson...contemplated Betsen or maybe Lewsey.....just didn't happen
 
L

Los Lover

Guest
Originally posted by Los Lover@Feb 27 2005, 10:56 PM
Mmmmmm....

OK - current...mixture of form and bias!

1. Vetiyaki (spell check)...cos looking at him makes you laugh with fear!
or, more realisticly, Du Randt
2. Kevin Mealamu
3. Carl Hayman
4. Victor Matfield
5. Chris Jack
6. George Smith
7. Richard McCaw
8. Jerry Collins

9. George Gregan

10. Daniel Carter (kicker)

11. Joe Rokocoko
12. Matt Giteau
13. Stirling Mortlock
14. Sitiveni Sivivatu
15. Matt Rogers

reserves: Saimone Taumopeau, Jeremy Paul, Sione Lauaki, Phil Waugh, Carlos Spencer, Tana Umaga, Rupeni Caucaunibuca (all either solid or capable of making an impact)

Oh oh! Where are all my NH players?



nah just jokes.....even though admittedly I have none. I came close to adding Robinson...contemplated Betsen or maybe Lewsey.....just didn't happen


Sorry!

I would have O'Driscoll in the reserves, possibly even starting ahead of Mortlock.....my bad.
 
R

richees

Guest
Originally posted by WALES FOREVER@Feb 25 2005, 11:06 AM
Who Will be your best 15 just a bit of fun !!!!


This is mine :

1, Duncan Jones (Wales)
2, Smit (S.A)
3, Julian White (England)
4, Malcom O'Kelly (Ireland)
5, Norm Maxwell (N Z)
6, Shalk Burger (S.A)
7, Serge Betsen (France)
8, J. Van Nierkirk (S.A)

9, George Gregan (Austrailia)
10, Jonny Wilkinson (England)
11, Shane Williams (Wales)
12, Tana Umaga (N Z)
13, Brian O'Driscoll (Ireland)
14, Rupeni CauCau (Fiji)
15, Jason Robinson (England)

REPS:
M.Mulliaiana, D.Howllet, G.Smith, R.McCaw, C.Charvis, P.Montgomery, J.Lomu (legend) JOSH KRONFELD (HERO).oh and Joe R

Thats it for me not mutch thought but off the top of my head.

P.S Sorry Guys kronfeld prob aint in the game but hve to have him in any team i mention he Rocks!!!!!!!!
almost perfect team, but paul o'connell should be in instead of o'kelly. he's the best 2nd row in the world, possible lions captain also
 
C

cavan

Guest
what's the fascination with Chris Jack anyhow? O'Connell and O'Kelly are superior.
 
1

187

Guest
Originally posted by Los Lover@Feb 28 2005, 02:54 AM
Sorry!

I would have O'Driscoll in the reserves, possibly even starting ahead of Mortlock.....my bad.
Nah man my team will hav Mortlock at centre...

1. Saimone Taumoepeau
2. Aleki Lutui
3. Taufa'ao Filise
4. Ross Kennedy
5. O'kelly
6. Cliff Palu
7. George Smith
8. Jerry Collins
9. Kevin Senio
10. Luke McCallister
11. Shane Williams
12. Henson (Wales 2nd 5... wuts his 1st name?)
13. Stirling Mortlock
14. Lote Tuqiri
15. Mat Rogers
 
H

Handsomebob

Guest
Just for fun:
My All time Franc XV :

1 Christian Califano ( 90's)
2 jeff Tordo (90's)
3 Pieter De Villiers (Current)
4 Olivier Merle (80's to 90's)
5 Fabien Pelous (Current)
6 Jean Pierre Rives (70's)
7 Laurent Cabannes (90's)
8 Abdel Benazzi (90's)
9 Fabien Galthié (90's to 00's)
10 Frank Mesnel (90's)
11 Phillipe St André (90's)
12 Jo Maso (70's)
13 Phillipe Sella (80's to 90's)
14 Emile Ntamack (90's )
15 Serge Blanco (80's)
 
S

samoan stallion

Guest
1, Os Du Rant (S.A)
2, ?? ... poss Keven Mealamu if he threw consistently
3, Pieter De Villiers (France)
4, Malcom O'Kelly (Ireland)
5, Chris Jack (NZ)
6, Shalk Burger (S.A) OR Serge Betsen (France)
7, George Smith (Aus) OR Richie McCaw (NZ)
8, Martin Corry (Eng) OR Jerry Collins (NZ)
9, George Gregan (Austrailia)
10, Jonny Wilkinson (England)
11, Joe Rocokoko (NZ)
12, Gordon Darcy (Ireland) OR Matt Giteau (Aus)
13, Brian O'Driscoll (Ireland)
14, Rupeni CauCau (Fiji) OR Lote Tuqiri (Aus)
15, Mils Muliaina (NZ)

An Irish midfield with Fijian wingers .... and a Fly Half who tackles like an Islander ...
 
C

cavan

Guest
not bad dude, but i can't stand people who write up fav team withs the likes of:

10. Carlos Spencer/Dan Carter/Johnny Wilkinson

The whole point is that you make a decision about your fav 15, not like 20!
 
S

samoan stallion

Guest
Fair comment ..... exclude the players after ' OR ' on my list and that's the 1st Fifteen ....
 
T

top gun

Guest
My Greatest All Black team

15. Christian Cullen
14. Jeff Wilson
13. Frank Bunce
12. Dan Carter
11. Joe Rokococo
10. Grant Fox
9. Graham Bachop
8. Zinzan Brooke
7. Richie McCaw
6. Michael Jones
5. Robin Brooke
4. Ian Jones
3. Olo Brown
2. Sean Fitzpatrick
1. Craig Dowd
 
S

samoan stallion

Guest
15. Christian Cullen
14. Jeff Wilson
13. Frank Bunce
12. Walter Litte
11. Jonah Lomu
10. Andrew Mehrtens
9. Graham Bachop
8. Zinzan Brooke
7. Josh Kronfield
6. Michael Jones
5. Colin Meads
4. Ian Jones
3. Olo Brown
2. Sean Fitzpatrick
1. Craig Dowd

Pretty much, the 1995 world cup team except for Colin Meads, Christian Cullen ... and i think Michael Jones, who missed out on the squad because of his faith i.e. he didn't play on Sundays.
 
C

captainamerica

Guest
Originally posted by samoan stallion@Mar 3 2005, 09:38 AM
and i think Michael Jones, who missed out on the squad because of his faith i.e. he didn't play on Sundays.
I think Michael Jones did enough in his career to warrant a place in anyones World/Best/Awesome/Coolest/Rockingest XV without the '95 cup.
 
Top