Can I suggest an alternative to the hall of fame. Rather than debating whether a player should be inducted into the hall of fame maybe we could just talk about players and a particular moment that they had that was memorable. This could be an example of when they played an awesome game, or maybe did something off the field that deserves merit. Posters could write up a quick summary of what happened and it wouldn't involve huge discussion. It would also be a chance to learn about players that we previously did not know much about.