Pre and post world cup dream XV's

Discussion in 'General Rugby Union' started by sj10, Aug 7, 2007.

  1. sj10

    sj10 Guest

    I wondered how people's dream teams would change before and after the world cup

    So I would like as many people to list their World XV before the World Cup starts, and list another after the final, and see the difference. Here's mine

    Thomas
    Sivivatu
    O'Driscoll
    Giteau
    Strettle
    Carter
    Peel

    Sheridan
    Ibanez
    Hayman
    Jack
    O'Connell
    Jason White
    McCaw
    Chabal

    Bit undecided in places, had to leave out Owen, Martyn Williams, D'Arcy and Wilkinson.

    What d'you think. Please post
     
  2. Forum Ad Advertisement

  3. paco1

    paco1 Guest


    HAHAHAHAA PEEL!!! HAHAHAHAAA!!!
    THOMAS????? THAMAS WHO???????? THOMAS CASTAGNIEDE?????? HAHAHAHA

    HERE´S ANOTHER ONE: MIKE CATT!!!!!!!!! HAHAHA
     
  4. ospreys1987

    ospreys1987 Guest


    HAHAHAHAA PEEL!!! HAHAHAHAAA!!!
    THOMAS????? THAMAS WHO???????? THOMAS CASTAGNIEDE?????? HAHAHAHA

    HERE´S ANOTHER ONE: MIKE CATT!!!!!!!!! HAHAHA [/b][/quote]


    You an idiot or just so anti-Welsh that you cant see that Dwayne Peel is clearly one of, if not the best, scrumhalfs in the world? I admit I have said that I think Phillips should start for Wales as he is the future number one scrumhalf but Peel is clearly one of the best in the world. Although I disagree with Alfie being in the team, he's nowhere near the best fullback in the world IMO

    but my world XV would be

    15 Hernandez.
    14. Bryan Habana
    13. Brian O'Driscoll
    12. Mils Muliaina
    11. SIvivatu
    10. Dan Carter
    9. Dwanye Peel

    1. Andrew Sheridan (he has his doubters but I think hes an amazing scrummager)
    2. Rafael Ibanez
    3. Carl Hayman
    4. Paul O' Connell
    5. Alun Wyn Jones
    6. Jerry Collins
    7. Richie McCaw
    8. Chabal
     
  5. wlshby09

    wlshby09 Guest

    15. Chris Lathem

    14. Brian Habana

    13. Brain O'Driscoll

    12. Matt Giteau

    11. Joe Rokococo

    10. Dan Carter

    9. Dwayne Peel



    1. Tony Woodcock

    2. Kevin Mealamu

    3. Carl Hayman

    4. Alun Wyn Jones

    5. Cris Jack

    6. Jerry Collins

    7. Richie Mccaw

    8. Rodney So'oialo
     
  6. Juggernaut

    Juggernaut Guest

    1. CJ Van Der Linde
    2. Keven Mealamu
    3. Carl Hayman
    4. Simon Shaw
    5. Keith Robinson
    6. Simon Easterby
    7. Richie McCaw
    8. Juan Smith

    9. Shaun Perry
    10. Steve Larkham
    11. Jason Robinson
    12. Luke McAlister
    13. Brian O'Driscoll
    14. Joe Rokocoko
    15. Francois Steyn
     
  7. darwin_23

    darwin_23 Guest

    1 Tony Woodcock
    2 Kevin Mealamu
    3 Carl Hayman
    4 Victor Matfield
    5 Paul O'Connell
    6 Jerry Collins
    7 Richie McCaw
    8 Sergio Parisse

    9 Fourie du Preez
    10 Dan Carter
    11 Sitivini Siviatau
    12 Gordon D'Arcy
    13 Brian O'Driscoll
    14 Brian Habana
    15 Chris Latham

    Close calls were at hooker (there were no real standouts), Lock (Botha, Vickermann), Number 8 (So'ioalo, Leamy), second-five (Jauzion), and fullback (Muliana).
     
  8. SecondRow04

    SecondRow04 Guest

    1 Andrew Sheridan
    2 Mark Regan
    3 Phil Vickery
    4 Simon Shaw
    5 Paul O'Connell
    6 Jerry Collings
    7 Richie McCaw
    8 Nick Easter

    9 Shaun Perry
    10 Johnny Wilkinson
    11 Joe Rokococo
    12 Gordan D'arcy
    13 Brian O'Driscoll
    14 Jason Robinson
    15 Francois Steyn

    would probably have on bench:

    16 Raphel Ibanez
    17 Os Du Rant
    18 Chris Jack
    19 Serge Betsen
    20 Daniel Carter
    21 Andy Farrell
    22 Dave Strettle

    thatll do it
     
  9. Dmx#1

    Dmx#1 Guest

    Hmm im quite surprised you picked Wilkinson over Carter in the starting lineup. I wont disagree until i see both of the peform at the world cup. Carter hasn't been in top form at the moment so gee i dunno. Everyones enitled to their own oppinion
     
  10. SecondRow04

    SecondRow04 Guest

    they are very good players but like you sed carter hasnt been on top form latley and wilkinson seems to be finding his so i went with him
     
  11. DC

    DC Guest

    shaun perry over fourie du preez, dwayne peel, byron kelleher?!?!
     
  12. Juggernaut

    Juggernaut Guest

    It's a close call in some positions..
     
  13. Bullitt

    Bullitt Guest

    My thoughts exactly; Perry isn't even the best in England, let alone the world.
     
  14. ospreys1987

    ospreys1987 Guest

    Isnt Shaun Perry only playing because Harry Ellis is injured? Surely Perry is no where near the best in England nevermind the world
     
  15. McAlister

    McAlister Guest

    1. G.Steenkamp
    2. G.Botha
    3. C.Hayman
    4. B.Botha
    5. C.Jack
    6. S.Burger
    7. R.McCaw
    8. J.Collins but if spies are in he will be nr1 8

    9. F.du Preez
    10. S.Larkham
    11. B.Habana
    12. L.McAlister
    13. J.de Villiers / B. O'driscoll
    14. J.Rockoko
    15. D.Carter
     
  16. McAlister

    McAlister Guest

    Fourie is clearly one of the best scrumhalfs. so what is the point?
    I think Wilkinsen is in beter form then Carter and Larkham are the best Flyhalf now. For flyhalf it is hard to choose a man
     
  17. Karmabass

    Karmabass Guest

    1. John Hayes
    2. Rapheal Ibanez
    3. Martin Castrogiovanni
    4. Sebastian Chabal
    5. Paul O'Connell
    6. Schlack Burger
    7. Richie McCaw
    8. Sergio Parisse

    9. Dwayne Peel
    10. Steve Larkham
    11. Denis Hickie
    12. Yannick Jauzion
    13. Brian O'Driscoll
    14. Brian Habana
    15. Chris Latham
     
  18. sj10

    sj10 Guest

    I think at least one italian should be in there, probably parisse or mauro bergamasco, but it wud be ludicrous to drop mccaw at the expense. Jason White is absolutely immense, guaranteed for the 6 spot, but Betsen, Collins or Simon Easterby run him close.

    But remember the point is to make a team after the world cup and compare
     
  19. 1) Sheridan
    2) Flannery
    3) Hayman
    4) O'Connell
    5) Matfield
    6) Burger
    7) McCaw
    8) Spies
    9) Gregan
    10) Carter
    11) Rockoko
    12) D'Arcy
    13) O'Driscoll
    14) Habana
    15) Hernandez

    16) Ibanez
    17) Woodcock
    18) Jack
    19) Leamy
    20) Peel
    21) Wilkinson
    22) Mortlock
     
Enjoyed this thread? Register to post your reply - click here!

Share This Page