Top 10 Fly-Halfs In the World

[artosaari]

1. Jonny Wilkinson
2. Stephen Larkham

in no particular order

Carlos Spencer
Dan Carter
Ronan O'Gara
Butch James
Lionel Beauxis
Federic Michalak
James Hook
Nick Evans

 

[melon]

1. Jonny Wilkinson
2. Stephen Larkham

in no particular order

Carlos Spencer
Dan Carter
Ronan O'Gara
Butch James
Lionel Beauxis
Federic Michalak
James Hook
Nick Evans [/b]

I'm not trying to come across as a prick, rather I'm just voicing my opinion of your selections.

Why have you put Johnny Wilkinson at #1? Against Samoa he didn't show any real world-class playmaking skills, all he did was kick. He is one of the best kickers in the world and given a little more time will be back to the best, however his playmaking ability is nowhere near that of Carter, Larkham or Spencer.

His performance last night was of about O'Gara or Hook standard. Not even that.

I'd have Wilkinson in my top 10, but not in the top 4...at the moment anyway.

 

[Gaizka]

1. Federic Michalak
2. Dan Carter
3. Ronan O' Gara
4. Johnny Wilkinson
....

 

[dobduff11]

1 Giteau
2 Carter
3 Evans
4 Skrela
5 Hook
6 Hernandez
7 Contepomi
8 O'Gara
9 Paterson
10 Cipriani

 

[sambãd5]

evans
giteau
carter.

in that order too. evans is on fire atm (well, prior to geting injured. and will carve up any team. and when nacewa gets back, their 10/15 combo is hard to beat.

 

[RxTim]

is skrela really that good? i thought he looked awful in the 6N's

 

[wilmartin]

Jonny Wilkinson is number 1 when hes on form, followed by dan carter, and O'Gara, Carlos spencer is to risky.

 

[shtove]

Nobody rates Stephen Jones, the most consistent of all?

He will lead Wales to victory against the world champions this summer.

 

[Jer1cho]

He will lead Wales to victory against the world champions this summer.
[/b]

:lol2tn:
Ha ha. Wales beating South Africa at home. Something Australia hasn't even done in 9 years. Good luck.

 

[Incredible Schalk]

Didnt SA hammer Wales at home only a few months ago, to be fair i expect it to be fairly close. Similar to how Ireland did in 2004.

1-Carter
2-Evans
3-Giteau
4-Butch James
5-Cipriani
6-Hook
7-Contepomi
8-B Barnes
9-Wilkinson
10-O'Gara

How anyone can rate Michalak in their top 10 i dont know, Skrele is cack as well..

 

[Fushitsusha]

At the moment I think the top 3 in no particular order MUST include Carter, Evans and Giteau.

After that - I don't know......

 

[dwepener]

i geddit feed their cockeyness and then..... BANG back in auckland before the semis [/b]

Carter and Nick Evans miles ahaead of the rest.

going into the wc who do you think the top 10 fly halfs are. id go with

1 Dan Carter
2 Ronan O'Gara
3 Steven Larkham
4 Felipe Contipome
5 Butch James
6 David Skrela
7 James Hook
8 Johnny Wilkinson
9 Chris Paterson
10 Nick Evans [/b]

Yeah but Nick Evans has been awesome this season

<div class='quotemain'> i geddit feed their cockeyness and then..... BANG back in auckland before the semis [/b]

Carter and Nick Evans miles ahaead of the rest.

going into the wc who do you think the top 10 fly halfs are. id go with

1 Dan Carter
2 Ronan O'Gara
3 Steven Larkham
4 Felipe Contipome
5 Butch James
6 David Skrela
7 James Hook
8 Johnny Wilkinson
9 Chris Paterson
10 Nick Evans [/b]

Yeah but Nick Evans has been awesome this season





[/b][/quote]

 

[rodri_arg91]

1- carter
2- larkham
3- wilkinson
4- contepomi
5- o'gara
6- hook
7- michalak
8- pretorius
9- todeschini
10- evans

dont forget about two legends: Hugo Porta and Tony Brown (i always liked Tony lol)

 

[nielvdheever]

going into the wc who do you think the top 10 fly halfs are. id go with

1 Dan Carter
2 Ronan O'Gara
3 Steven Larkham
4 Felipe Contipome
5 Butch James
6 David Skrela
7 James Hook
8 Johnny Wilkinson
9 Chris Paterson
10 Nick Evans

maybe you should put in F. Michalak

 

[Dmx#1]

i geddit feed their cockeyness and then..... BANG back in auckland before the semis



Carter and Nick Evans miles ahaead of the rest.

I agree with Giteau coming third

 

[toutai]

1 Dan Carter
2 juan hernandez
3 Johnny Wilkinson
4 Carlos Spencer
Steven Larkham
Chris Paterson
Nick Evans

 

[candybum]

cant speak of NH fly halves so...

1 Evans
2 Carter
3 Giteau
4 Donald
5 Grant
... Cant think of 10

 

[melon]

cant speak of NH fly halves so...

1 Evans
2 Carter
3 Giteau
4 Donald
5 Grant
... Cant think of 10 [/b]

You can add Michalak and Berrick Barnes to that (players in the SH)

 

[candybum]

<div class='quotemain'> cant speak of NH fly halves so...

1 Evans
2 Carter
3 Giteau
4 Donald
5 Grant
... Cant think of 10 [/b]

You can add Michalak and Berrick Barnes to that (players in the SH)
[/b][/quote]

lol ok

6 Michalak
7 Barnes (berrick not wayne)
8 Beale
9 houggard
10 and the rest

 

[peppers07]

In no order
Ogara
giteau
Carter
Cipriani
Contepomi
Hernandez
Hook
No others that i get to see play stand out