- Joined
- Oct 17, 2013
- Messages
- 16,966
- Reaction score
- 4,333
- Location
- Propping up the bar in the Clubhouse
I mean if it was federal before Ireland gained independence, it still would have been unworkable. You either would have had massive over-representation by the non-English nations to compensate for their much lower population or you would have had England dominating the whole thing due to having more population than the rest combined. England would have had to be split up to make it work, which itself would have been controversial. If you broke up each nation to have equal size regions, you basically just have the same as we have now but with larger "constituencies".
Well, if we look at Canada and Australia as countries where they have made a federal type structures work. Even with a constitutional monarch. Of course the split between different countries powers would need to worked out properly/with representation. Not without its issues for sure. But this whole devolution from Blair’s years was a half arsed attempt at a federal structure to appease Scotland, Wales and NI. Not having a proper written constitution hasn’t helped either.




