Top 10 Fly-Halfs In the World

[lebarde]

Brock James !

 

[Jer1cho]

If every fly half was on their peak form, Jonny Wilkinson. But for now, Dan Carter is still the master...

 

[Blastab]

1st - Dan Carter
2nd - O' Gara

 

[peppers07]

In no order
Ogara
giteau
Carter
Cipriani
Contepomi
Hernandez
Hook
No others that i get to see play stand out

 

[kick2touch]

Carter, Evans, Larkham, O'Gara, Contemponi are the top five in no order
Cipriani, Hook, Hernandez, Beauxis, Giteau, James, Jones, Wilkinson, are all of note

 

[ingres]

1 Dan Carter
2 Ronan O'Gara
3 Larkham
4 Contepomi
5 michalak
6 Wilkinson
7 David Skrela
8 Hernandez
9 Fred Michalak
10 Lionel Beaux

 

[Jer1cho]

1 Dan Carter
2 Ronan O'Gara
3 Larkham
4 Contepomi
5 michalak
6 Wilkinson
7 David Skrela
8 Hernandez
9 Fred Michalak
10 Lionel Beaux
[/b]

The world cup winning fly half Butch James not on your list? Strange...

 

[Bullitt]

Even stranger that Ronan O'Choka is...

 

[danny]

1 Dan Carter
2 Ronan O'Gara
3 Larkham
4 Contepomi
5 michalak
6 Wilkinson
7 David Skrela
8 Hernandez
9 Fred Michalak
10 Lionel Beaux
[/b]

Michelak is in your top ten twice, he must be good!

 

[soumik16]

dan carter
ronan o gara
jonny wilkinson
juan martin hernandez
butch james
fred michalak
stephen larkham
james hooks
dan parks
nick evans

 

[wadec]

MERHTS!

 

[peppers07]

Why are people saying Dan Parks he is a **** passer kicks away all posesion only average defensively

 

[EvanM]

For me it's 1 Dan Carter
2 Ronan O'Gara
3 Steven Larkham
4 Felipe Contipome
5 Butch James
6 David Skrela
7 James Hook
8 Johnny Wilkinson
9 Chris Paterson
10 Nick Evans

 

[Sir Speedy]

For me it's 1 Dan Carter
2 Ronan O'Gara
3 Steven Larkham
4 Felipe Contipome
5 Butch James
6 David Skrela
7 James Hook
8 Johnny Wilkinson
9 Chris Paterson
10 Nick Evans
[/b]

No Hernandez? :blink: Sorry, the bigger joke is you included Larkham, O'Gara at 2, Wilkinson, Paterson (seriously ROFL?) and Skrela...dear God...

 

[jaco]

Dan Carter
Butch James
Nick Evans
Johnny Wilkinson
Ronan O'Gara
Matt Giteau
Stephan Larkham
Frans Steyn
Carlos Spencer
Freddie Michalak

 

[tommowins]

1. Carter
2. B. James
3. Hernandez
4. Giteau
5. O'Gara
6. S. Jones
7. F. Contempomi
8. Wilkinson
9. Skrela
10. Evans

 

[KZNSharksFan]

This list encompasses all recent flyhalves, assuming they're on top form

1)Carter=Mehrtens
3)Spencer
4)Larkham
5)Giteau
6)Wilkinson
7)Butch!
8)Evans
9)Michalak
10)No one else really worthy

This list takes into account players actual performance and consistency- hence a more relevant and accurate list i think.

1)Mehrtens
3)Carter
4)Larkham
5)Giteau
6)Evans
7)Butch!

 

[oli_taylor]

Top 10... Wilkinson (although always injured), Carter, Spencer, James, Steyn, Grant, Hook, Giteau (Is he really a fly half though??), Barkley (Should be fly half... wasted at centre),

+ 1

Next year though....

Hook, Cipriani, Carter, Ryan Lamb, Olly Barkley, James, Grant, Matthew Jones, Joe Carlisle,

and me when I move from prop/lock to fly half for uni

 

[Sir Speedy]

This list encompasses all recent flyhalves, assuming they're on top form

7)Butch!

This list takes into account players actual performance and consistency- hence a more relevant and accurate list i think.

7)Butch!
[/b]

I'm surprised you rated Butch James so lowly. Surely on current form he is the best or 2nd best fly-half in the World? IMO, he was your best back in the 2 test series (uh, besides De Villiers who is in outstanding form atm) - his passing was brilliant and the fact he always had people running onto the ball made his job so much easier. I don't think he made a single mistake in the two games either...the bugger. <_<

 

[KZNSharksFan]

<div class='quotemain'>
This list encompasses all recent flyhalves, assuming they're on top form

7)Butch!

This list takes into account players actual performance and consistency- hence a more relevant and accurate list i think.

7)Butch!
[/b]

I'm surprised you rated Butch James so lowly. Surely on current form he is the best or 2nd best fly-half in the World? IMO, he was your best back in the 2 test series (uh, besides De Villiers who is in outstanding form atm) - his passing was brilliant and the fact he always had people running onto the ball made his job so much easier. I don't think he made a single mistake in the two games either...the bugger. <_<
[/b][/quote]


Mehrtens and carter are in a league of their own, but the rest are pretty close, it hurt me to put Butch at the bottom, but he doesnt rip the opposition backline apart like the others often do