2015 LHP: Vunipola, Marler
2019 LHP: Vunipola, Marler, Genge
2015 HK: George, Youngs, Webber
2019 HK: George, Cowan-Dickie, Singleton
2015 THP: Cole, Wilson, Brookes
2019 THP: Cole, Sinckler
2015 LK: Parling, Kruis, Lawes, Launchbury
2019 LK: Itoje, Kruis, Lawes, Launchbury
2015 FL: Robshaw, Haskell, Wood
2019 FL: Curry, Underhill, Ludlam
2015 #8: Easter, Vunipola, Morgan
2019 #8: Vunipola, Wilson
2015 SH: Youngs, Care, Wigglesworth
2019 SH: Youngs, Heinz
2015 FH: Farrell, Ford
2019 FH: Farrell, Ford
2015 CE: Barritt, Joseph, Slade, [Redacted]
2019 CE: Tuilagi, Joseph, Slade, Francis
2015 WG: May, Nowell, Watson
2019 WG: May, Nowell, Cokanasiga, McConnochie
2015 FB: Brown, Goode
2019 FB: Daly, Watson
IMO 2019 Vunipola and Marler are better than their 2015 vintage
2019 George is significantly better than 2015 George, but Youngs was better the LCD is right now. Neither 3rd choice is going to worry about anyone.
2019 Cole is way less effective than himself in 2015, but Wilson was better then than Sinckler is just yet - though Sinckler has a much higher ceiling.
Itoje is so much better than Parling; whilst Kruis and Lawes are probably more effective now; Launchbury probably isn't.
This year's backrow is so much more capable, but do they have that gnarled cynicism that the best have?
SH: gods dammit what I wouldn't give for a decent scrum half
2019 Farrell wipes the floor with 2015 Farrell, whilst Ford has added more nouse, but has lost some of the excitement in the process.
Each of those centres is a big step up on their 2015 competitors; with the possible exception of Francis vs [Redacted]
May, Nowell and Watson are all better players now, Johnny out of all recognition - but by gods we could do with a FB that was actually accustomed to playing there. Coka adds a real fear factor though.
HopefullySo this time England get out of the pool.
Despite the same concerns as everyone else (Tighthead & Scrum Half numbers), I'm actually fairly happy with the squad.
Despite the same concerns as everyone else (Tighthead & Scrum Half numbers), I'm actually fairly happy with the squad.
If we play a similar side to the one that started yesterday with McConnochie in for Watson against Tonga and USA, it gives us a good opportunity to put out our best side fresh against Argentina and France.
It's all bluster with nearly a week in between games if someone doesn't make the 22 an injury replacement can be called up pretty sharpish.
Once you get beyond bench cover it doesn't really matter of the player is on the plane or not.
For instant do you really believe if Youngs or Heinz, Ford really will be our bench option?
The trouble is, those replacements are permanent.It's all bluster with nearly a week in between games if someone doesn't make the 22 an injury replacement can be called up pretty sharpish.
Once you get beyond bench cover it doesn't really matter of the player is on the plane or not.
For instant do you really believe if Youngs or Heinz, Ford really will be our bench option?
McConnochie is only in the squad until Nowell proves his fitness. One will drop out and Williams will replace them.
Its obvious.
I know Marler played some 3 growing up - think he played there a bit for the U20s didn't he? Unfortunately, I also remember him saying on a podcast that he'd never consider playing tighthead at professional level as he thinks it's too dangerous for the inexperienced, so unless Eddie's pulled some magic on him then I can't see him being an option.Marler at 3 is pretty crazy,
Would feel better about Williams/Sinckler at loosehead - isn't tighthead the more technical of the two positions?
I know Marler played some 3 growing up - think he played there a bit for the U20s didn't he? Unfortunately, I also remember him saying on a podcast that he'd never consider playing tighthead at professional level as he thinks it's too dangerous for the inexperienced, so unless Eddie's pulled some magic on him then I can't see him being an option.
As you said, TH is the more technical of the 2 positions, and so frankly I think Mako would get f***ed up there as he barely has a handle on LH.
Genge is still new to propping having only moved there from the back row in the last few years. Chucking him in at TH for the first time at international level would be suicide.
In short, from what I can see we have 0 THP cover in the squad.
I also think he's been bloody stupid announcing so early. I understand the certainty point, but if player A gets injured it's not always necessarily a case of a straight swap for player B when you consider all the permutations of covering other positions. Not to mention that if any of the newbies don't cut it in the warm ups he can't can them for the experienced option - well he can, we haven't officially declared yet, but not without getting serious egg on his face. Why tie your hands like that?
I've no problem with Fast Eddie naming squad so early
No point wasting time with camp bodies & those who've no shot of making RWC Squad
I can't believe we are genuinely risking the possibility of forfeiting a World Cup match. I mean, I can't see WR allowing it to happen, they'll bend the rules I'm sure, but other countries will be rightly furious. I don't look forward to the Welsh/Scottish/Irish/Kiwis/Saffas/Everyone in the match thread if that happens....The trouble is, those replacements are permanent.
For example. If Sinckler fails an HIA against Tonga, he has a 6 day return-,to-pkay, and misses the USA match. Do you really send him home for the rest of the tournament? Or do you try to convince the ref that Marker is actually a THP after all? If you fail in to convince them we can't field a 23. I'm not sure if we could potentially revert to a 7-man bench or simply forfeit the match.
"The necessary number of reserve front row players must be included in the 31 man squad to cover last minute injuries to the front row players in the match day squad due to the 48 hour limit on injury replacements from outside the tournament squad."I can't believe we are genuinely risking the possibility of forfeiting a World Cup match. I mean, I can't see WR allowing it to happen, they'll bend the rules I'm sure, but other countries will be rightly furious. I don't look forward to the Welsh/Scottish/Irish/Kiwis/Saffas/Everyone in the match thread if that happens....
Im actually surprised there isn't a rule about having enough front row cover in the squad like there is for the match day 23