2019 Flankers are such an improvement over 2015 flankers...And far less egos.
Well you say that.....
Curry may well be on track for great things, but still early days and he has plenty of scope to get better. Underhill's had a couple of great moments but injuries have stopped his career getting much momentum, while none of us have a clue what Ludlam's really about. For these purposes I'm counting Wilson as an 8 but if you include him as a flanker, yes he's had some excellent games, but there have been a few quiet ones too.
2015 flankers were Wood, Robshaw and Haskell. 6.5s all. So with Curry being an out and out 7 there's automatically a better balance this time round.
It's easy, very easy, to malign the 2015 vintage. None will go down as greats, but you don't rack up 50+ caps as they all did by being total mugs. That RWC 15 was a disaster went way beyond the back row.
Robshaw was often pitted against some of the best 7s around including McCaw. Not a natural 7, always gave it all he had. Sometimes bested, but generally came away with head held high enough and several MoM awards. Poor captain though.
Haskell won a man of the series award in Aus. He was big and horrible and sometimes I think we concentrated on the bad (of which there was plenty), and not giving enough credit when he did things well (also plenty). That may have been partly because he was a big character and stuck his head up above the parapet. Don't underestimate character, squads need those types. Who are the big characters this time who will be the focal points and glue the 19 squad together over six long weeks, let alone leading on the field?
Wood was MoM in win against the ABs and the best line out option out of any of these by a distance. Talking about the captaincy coloured a lot of opinions, but he still had some decent games.
Straight after the RWC was our 17 match winning run. In 16 of those at least one of the 2015 three was in the starting XV, on 10 occasions two of them. Will we see the current crop be part of something like that?
At the start of RWC 15 Wood Hask and Robshaw had 137 caps between them. Ludlam, Wilson, Underhill and Curry have a paltry 34. They may have potentially higher ceilings but, broken record time, that experience matters.
So I think all we can say is that they may potentially become better players. But the acid test is how they'll stand up against fully psyched Saffers, Kiwis, Welsh or Irish in a pressured RWC match with a lot at stake. Not sure on that yet.
Flame me!