I think it was built up too much by the forum guys who played it before release - not the first time that's happened on here though!!
I don't mind the graphics, and there are certain things in the game I prefer over Rugby 06, such as the camera angle, goal kicking, player AI (ie all 15 defenders don't bunch together and run in a straight line directly at the ball!) ... but there are too many things actually broken which spoil playability:
- turnovers are virtually impossible (almost enforces use of the big hit button)
- rucks are way too slow
- kicking from hand is a waste of time, and too sensitive
I played JLR again the other week whilst stuck in bed after an operation, and it is still more playable than this. You are in control of lineouts, rucks are only as slow as it takes the Scrumhalf to reach the breakdown rather than waiting for when the animation is over (plus possession can change several times over the course of a single ruck!), kicking from hand is easier, and the rolling mauls are still unsurpassed.
Others may complain that RC2006 is rubbish as it has no set plays / SH teams etc. - but neither did JLR, and that was still more playable than RC2006 I'm afraid - sorry Trevor!
Now if they had been trying to make a rugby league game - this would have been a very good starting point ...