Lions squad on current form.

Discussion in 'General Rugby Union' started by Prestwick, Mar 15, 2007.

  1. Prestwick

    Prestwick Guest

    And here is the Lions if picked by Will Carling right now:
    15 Dempsey


    14 Horgan

    13 O'Driscoll

    12 D'Arcy

    11 Strettle


    10 Hook

    9 Ellis


    8 Leamy

    7 Wallace

    6 Easterby


    5 O'Connell

    4 Murray


    3 Murray

    2 Best

    1 Jenkins

    I would like to take NO RESPONSIBILITY for the above squad by the way, only merely see what people think of it.
     
  2. Forum Ad Advertisement

  3. St Day 3

    St Day 3 Guest

    Doomed- thats what i think of it.
     
  4. Rugby_Cymru

    Rugby_Cymru Guest

    I don't know why you listen to that podcast sometimes.
     
  5. An Tarbh

    An Tarbh Guest

    All that needs to be said is thank Christ he's not going to be picking the Lions team.
     
  6. Rugby_Cymru

    Rugby_Cymru Guest

    I think what he's done here is to try and pick a team with a lack of experience and a lack of current form.
    It's a good set up...really is.
     
  7. Prestwick

    Prestwick Guest

    The podcast is awesome, it has three of the best rugby players of the 1990s and their views. I take them at face value and on occasion, I agree with them! I agree with Will that Ieuan is a PC guy who won't give a straight answer about Wales lest he step on any Welsh toes (which makes a mockery of all this "red zone" stuff I keep hearing about) and I agree with Zinzan frequently as an independent Southern idiot!
     
  8. Bullitt

    Bullitt Guest

    Pick any Irish XV, that'd be better then mixing and matching the UK atm. Much as it would be pointless if you had a 2003 Lions and picked anyone non-English.
     
  9. King_D'Arcy

    King_D'Arcy Guest

    15 Dempsey: Rattling my brain he might be right here. Maybe it's just cause Dempsey's on form. But Paterson is his only real rival which is quite sad really.

    14 Horgan: Yup

    13 O'Driscoll: Yup

    12 D'Arcy: Yup

    11 Strettle: no!! Williams

    10 Hook: :huh: O'Gara or Parks or Wilkinson even. Anyone but Hook really

    9 Ellis: no!! Peel

    8 Leamy: Yup

    7 Wallace: Yup

    6 Easterby: popham perhaps

    5 O'Connell: Yup

    4 Murray: Dunno really to be honest

    3 Murray: : I suppose

    2 Best: He's not even the best hooker in Ireland

    1 Jenkins: Yup
     
  10. I'm suprised Carling's team is getting quite such a mauling.

    Yes, his forwards are a shambles, but I doubt they are his main focus.

    On current form alone, I doubt you could name a better Lions backline than the one he has picked. Yes, it's obvious players like Ellis, Hook and Strettle don't have much international experience compared to some others in the same position, but on current form I don't see anything wrong with his picks from 9-15.
     
  11. O'Rothlain

    O'Rothlain Guest

    He might as well said, "Screw it, we'll just send Ireland next Lions tour."
    Not that I'm complaining!!! I tend to agree.

    Maybe we should call them the Irish and British Lions? What do you think, Teh Mite?
     
  12. 15. Dempsey............unfortunately there's no-one else. We'll have to wait to see how Gareth Thomas does and Cueto if he gets his chance

    14. Horgan............no question

    13. O'Driscoll.........again no question

    12. D'Arcy ........obviously

    11. Strettle.........No experiance but looks a very exciting prospect

    10. O'Gara........has to be really

    9. Peel.......ellis is a joke

    8. Leamy......of course

    7. Wallace..........in the form of his life right now

    6. Worsley......probably not on current form but he's still a class act

    5. O'Connell......best 2nd row in the world

    4. O'Callaghan......have to keep him in there with POC

    3. Murray..........probably................there's nobody else

    2. Flannery........what is eddie o'sullivan thinking playing best ahead of him???

    1. Horan........everyone else is crap


    God Im after picking 11 irishmen! Not biased at all!
     
  13. An Tarbh

    An Tarbh Guest

    we'll see what we can come up with once this final round of the 6N is over. No doubt it'll certainly be better than what the 3 gimps came up with.
     
  14. 1) Jenkins

    2) Best (if Flannery had gotten more time I think I'd have picked him but Best was handy)

    3) Murray (not a great range to pick from, Vickery hasn't really impressed me)

    4) Paul O'Connell

    5) Donncha O'Callaghan

    6) Easterby

    7) Wallace (superb form)

    8) Leamy

    9) Ellis (narrowly pips Peel, I like his ability to break, created a great try against Wales)

    10) O'Gara (in spite of the misses today he's been consistently good and his physicality and support play have come on hugely)

    11) Hickie (will definitely be past it by the real lions tour, but has had a great tournament)

    12) D'Arcy

    13) BOD

    14) Horgan

    15) Dempsey (good game today, would like to have seen Thomas and maybe Robinson at 15 though)
    _
    16) Flannery, 17) Not sure, 18) Murray, 19) Best (would have liked to see more of him too), 20) Peel, 21) Wilkinson, 22) Robinson

    An apparently quite biased selection.. Dave Strettle and James Hook are both superb talents but at the moment I think their Irish counterparts are significantly better. This will probably not be the case in 2 years time though. Robinson's finishing was great in this tournament (after his drop in form after 2004 I thought he was past it) but Hickie's intelligence and skill level, and Horgan's power and height make them more valuable IMO.
     
  15. SecondRow04

    SecondRow04 Guest

    the lions squad has changed, apparently french and italian players can now be picked for the next tour...

    European Lions?

    so that surely should change it abit?
     
  16. If only.. With Italian front rowers, Irish 2nd row, back row and backs we could conquer the world..
     
  17. Read the N.B at th bottom!! :D :p
     
  18. SecondRow04

    SecondRow04 Guest

    oh yeah, i never saw that :(.... LOL!
     
  19. An Tarbh

    An Tarbh Guest

    No, stick with tradition, Lions has always been the 4 home nations, that's the beauty, no need to change it just cause we got a doing in NZ.
     
  20. shtove

    shtove Guest

    I always fall for April Fool's spoofs, but this time I twigged it about half way through when I saw the awful 'management speak'.

    Anyway - why does everyone write 'Dempsey' followed by 'unfortunately'? He's as solid a defender as you'll get, and has finished off many of Ireland's best moves in the last three years. What do these people want - Serge Blanco?? :%#%#:

    Carling's frontrow isn't going to frighten anyone.
     
  21. An Tarbh

    An Tarbh Guest

    well it's a good thing the tour isn't this year cause there's a few positions where we're quite weak at the moment, scrum half being the most worrying of all, Peel's form hasn't been up to much internationally and it's frightening to think that Harry Ellis looks the best bet out of the home nation scrum halves. Hooker is another problem position, last year Flannery would have been a shoe in but since he's not getting a look in with Best he can't really be considered on 20 minutes of gametime. Best has some serious problems with his game that have consistently popped up throughout the championship but again like Ellis he's the best of a bad lot. In form Peel and Flannery would be shoe ins for the Lions but at the moment we'd probably be stuck with Best and Ellis.
     
Enjoyed this thread? Register to post your reply - click here!

Share This Page