AP Final: Northampton Saints V Saracens, SAT 15:00 BST

[goodNumber10]

http://talksport.com/rugby-union/full-contact-sunday-june-1-14060293927

13 minutes in.... "not sour grapes". :lol:

Heheh!

 

[ratsapprentice]

That's the angle i'm basing it on. To me it looks like it leaves his hands/he doesn't have control.

I don't want to sound arrogant, or that I'm telling you what to think - but I don't accept that it's subjective.
That camera angle is definitive - it's a high res, high FPS camera with an unobscured view of his hands and the ball.

I accept that there is no absolutely definitive footage showing the ball touching the line - but it's beyond reasonable (i.e. non-biased/emotional) doubt that it was IMO.

 

[Tony Manx]

That's the angle i'm basing it on. To me it looks like it leaves his hands/he doesn't have control.


The other angles don't really show anything.

...actually it does not matter, the score and result is in the record book!!

 

[goodNumber10]

...actually it does not matter, the score and result is in the record book!!

Well quite, but then what is the point of this forum if not to discuss these things?

 

[goodNumber10]

I don't want to sound arrogant, or that I'm telling you what to think - but I don't accept that it's subjective.
That camera angle is definitive - it's a high res, high FPS camera with an unobscured view of his hands and the ball.

I accept that there is no absolutely definitive footage showing the ball touching the line - but it's beyond reasonable (i.e. non-biased/emotional) doubt that it was IMO.

Well I haven't got access to the footage so I'm basing it on watching the game two days ago in real-time.

In recollection it is how I saw it, maybe when I've afforded it the CSI-TRF treatment I'll agree.

 

[jonny24]

I also thought it was potentially knocked on, but I was watching at pretty low resolution so I could be wrong. Anyway, hell of exciting match. I feel bad for Saracens, not that I like them but I dislike them less.